🔬Modal Research Exchange

{
  "activation_gate": {
    "applicable": true,
    "checks": [
      {
        "measures": "model name passed to create_lora_training_client in every arm",
        "metric": "executed_base_model",
        "one_of": [
          "Qwen/Qwen3.5-2B"
        ]
      },
      {
        "measures": "type of params object passed to optim_step in each arm (logged client-side)",
        "metric": "executed_optimizer_step_type",
        "one_of": [
          "DimuonParams",
          "AdamParams"
        ]
      },
      {
        "max": 1.05,
        "measures": "||dB||_F^2 / (||dB||_2^2 * r) for the first DiMuon update of LoRA B, averaged over layers, from downloaded checkpoints at step 0 and 1",
        "metric": "dimuon_B_update_normalized_stable_rank_step1",
        "min": 0.6
      },
      {
        "max": 1.0,
        "measures": "fraction of the 100 training batches whose token-id hash is identical between paired arms within a seed",
        "metric": "batch_hash_match_across_arms",
        "min": 1.0
      },
      {
        "measures": "train token_mean NLL at step 0 minus step 10 in the DiMuon pilot at the middle LR; must be finite and positive",
        "metric": "pilot_train_nll_drop_dimuon_10steps",
        "min": 0.0
      }
    ],
    "reason": "The paired comparison only tests DiMuon if the executed optimizer really orthogonalizes LoRA B updates and both arms ran the declared configuration. Polar Express makes the first-step B update near-orthogonal (flat singular spectrum); AdamW's is not. This is measured from saved weight diffs, not SDK introspection."
  },
  "arms": [
    {
      "lr": 5e-05,
      "name": "lrsearch_adamw_5e-5_s0",
      "optimizer": "adam",
      "phase": "selection",
      "seed": 0,
      "steps": 40
    },
    {
      "lr": 0.0001,
      "name": "lrsearch_adamw_1e-4_s0",
      "optimizer": "adam",
      "phase": "selection",
      "seed": 0,
      "steps": 40
    },
    {
      "lr": 0.0002,
      "name": "lrsearch_adamw_2e-4_s0",
      "optimizer": "adam",
      "phase": "selection",
      "seed": 0,
      "steps": 40
    },
    {
      "lr": 0.0003,
      "name": "lrsearch_dimuon_3e-4_s0",
      "optimizer": "dimuon-lite",
      "phase": "selection",
      "seed": 0,
      "steps": 40
    },
    {
      "lr": 0.001,
      "name": "lrsearch_dimuon_1e-3_s0",
      "optimizer": "dimuon-lite",
      "phase": "selection",
      "seed": 0,
      "steps": 40
    },
    {
      "lr": 0.003,
      "name": "lrsearch_dimuon_3e-3_s0",
      "optimizer": "dimuon-lite",
      "phase": "selection",
      "seed": 0,
      "steps": 40
    },
    {
      "lr": "frozen from selection",
      "name": "baseline_adamw_s0",
      "optimizer": "adam",
      "phase": "confirmation",
      "seed": 0,
      "steps": 100
    },
    {
      "lr": "frozen from selection",
      "name": "baseline_adamw_s1",
      "optimizer": "adam",
      "phase": "confirmation",
      "seed": 1,
      "steps": 100
    },
    {
      "lr": "frozen from selection",
      "name": "baseline_adamw_s2",
      "optimizer": "adam",
      "phase": "confirmation",
      "seed": 2,
      "steps": 100
    },
    {
      "lr": "frozen from selection",
      "name": "treatment_dimuon_s0",
      "optimizer": "dimuon-lite",
      "phase": "confirmation",
      "seed": 0,
      "steps": 100
    },
    {
      "lr": "frozen from selection",
      "name": "treatment_dimuon_s1",
      "optimizer": "dimuon-lite",
      "phase": "confirmation",
      "seed": 1,
      "steps": 100
    },
    {
      "lr": "frozen from selection",
      "name": "treatment_dimuon_s2",
      "optimizer": "dimuon-lite",
      "phase": "confirmation",
      "seed": 2,
      "steps": 100
    }
  ],
  "base_model": "Qwen/Qwen3.5-2B",
  "baseline": "AdamW (tinker.AdamParams, beta1 0.9, beta2 0.95, eps 1e-8) through the same SDK script, with the same model, LoRA rank, init seed, batches and order, 100 steps, and eval. Its LR is chosen by the same 3-point validation search.",
  "batch_size": 32,
  "budget": {
    "gpu_hours": 2.0,
    "max_wall_minutes": 150
  },
  "command": "# Custom part: one SDK SFT loop shared by both optimizers (cookbook chat_sl is AdamW-only).\nimport os, sys, tinker, datasets, random\nfrom tinker_cookbook import renderers, tokenizer_utils\nfrom tinker_cookbook.supervised.data import conversation_to_datum\nOPT, LR, SEED, STEPS = sys.argv[1], float(sys.argv[2]), int(sys.argv[3]), int(sys.argv[4])\nMODEL='Qwen/Qwen3.5-2B'; BS=32; MAXLEN=2048\ntok=tokenizer_utils.get_tokenizer(MODEL); rend=renderers.get_renderer(renderers.get_recommended_renderer_name(MODEL) if hasattr(renderers,'get_recommended_renderer_name') else 'qwen3', tok)\nds=datasets.load_dataset('HuggingFaceH4/no_robots'); tr=list(ds['train']); random.Random(1234).shuffle(tr)\nval, train = tr[:500], tr[500:]; random.Random(SEED).shuffle(train)\nmk=lambda r: conversation_to_datum(r['messages'], rend, MAXLEN)\nsc=tinker.ServiceClient(base_url=os.environ['TINKER_BASE_URL'])\nkw={'optimizer': tinker.types.DimuonOptimizerConfig()} if OPT=='dimuon' else {}\ntc=sc.create_lora_training_client(base_model=MODEL, rank=32, seed=SEED, **kw)\ntc.save_weights_for_sampler(name=f'init-{OPT}-s{SEED}').result()  # hash for restoration preflight\nstep_params = (lambda: tinker.types.DimuonParams(learning_rate=LR, beta1=0.9, grad_clip_norm=0.0)) if OPT=='dimuon' else (lambda: tinker.AdamParams(learning_rate=LR, beta1=0.9, beta2=0.95, eps=1e-8))\nfor s in range(STEPS):\n    batch=[mk(r) for r in train[s*BS:(s+1)*BS]]\n    tc.forward_backward(batch, loss_fn='cross_entropy').result(); tc.optim_step(step_params()).result()\ndef nll(rows):  # token_mean from per-example totals, never batch loss:mean\n    tot=0.0; n=0.0\n    for i in range(0,len(rows),32):\n        d=[mk(r) for r in rows[i:i+32]]; out=tc.forward(d, loss_fn='cross_entropy').result()\n        for di,o in zip(d,out.loss_fn_outputs):\n            w=di.loss_fn_inputs['weights'].to_numpy(); lp=o['logprobs'].to_numpy(); tot+=-(lp*w).sum(); n+=w.sum()\n    return tot/n\nsplit = val if STEPS==40 else list(ds['test'])\nprint({'opt':OPT,'lr':LR,'seed':SEED,'steps':STEPS,'token_mean_nll':nll(split)})\ntc.save_weights_for_sampler(name=f'final-{OPT}-lr{LR}-s{SEED}').result()\n# run: python sft_opt.py {adam|dimuon} <lr> <seed> {40|100}",
  "correctness_preflight": {
    "notes": "Tolerances are fixed for bf16 LoRA weights with fp32 optimizer math before measuring. reference_update rtol 1e-2 leaves headroom over the reported 0.09% error. Feed the same LoRA state and gradient to the Spindle DiMuon step and to the reference for one step. With grad_clip_norm=0 and beta1 momentum seeded from the first gradient, the update should scale linearly in LR across a 100x span.",
    "paths": [
      {
        "baseline_revision": "UNRESOLVED: pin the modal-projects/spindle commit deployed at the shared Spindle URL (post-#85). AdamW updates on this deployment must match the pre-#85 AdamW update on identical grads/state.",
        "id": "spindle_dimuon_lite_optimizer",
        "kind": "optimizer",
        "lr_scaling": {
          "learning_rates": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "rtol": 0.01
        },
        "reference_revision": "UNRESOLVED: pin the commit of Aaron's DiMuon reconstruction (0.09% relative update error vs Tinker) and the modal-projects/miles commit of #17",
        "tolerances": {
          "baseline_update": {
            "atol": 1e-06,
            "min_cosine": 0.99999,
            "rtol": 0.001
          },
          "reference_update": {
            "atol": 1e-05,
            "min_cosine": 0.999,
            "rtol": 0.01
          }
        }
      }
    ],
    "required": true,
    "status": "unresolved: spindle and miles commits for #85/#17 and the commit of Aaron's DiMuon reconstruction must be pinned before any full sweep"
  },
  "dataset": {
    "hf_path": "HuggingFaceH4/no_robots",
    "n_examples": 9500,
    "name": "no_robots",
    "split": "train (9000 for training, 500 held out for LR selection); test (500) for confirmation"
  },
  "decision_rule": {
    "adaptive_selection": {
      "confirmation_item_ids": "all 500 rows of no_robots split=test",
      "kind": "hyperparameter",
      "rationale": "Muon-family and AdamW LoRA optimizers have very different good LRs. Each gets a prespecified 3-point grid, scored only on validation items held out from train, and the choice is frozen before the single confirmation eval on the test split.",
      "search_item_ids": "no_robots train rows held out by seeded shuffle (seed 1234), first 500 after shuffle; never used for training"
    },
    "alpha": 0.05,
    "assumptions": {
      "identically_distributed_seed_effects": true,
      "independent_seed_effects": true,
      "normal_seed_effects": true
    },
    "criteria": [
      {
        "id": "primary",
        "margin": 0.02,
        "metric": "no_robots_test_token_mean_nll_at_step_100",
        "weights": {
          "baseline": 1,
          "treatment": -1
        }
      }
    ],
    "estimand": "Reduction in held-out no_robots test token_mean NLL at step 100 from replacing AdamW with dimuon-lite (each at its validation-selected LR) for rank-32 LoRA SFT on Qwen3.5-2B; larger is better for dimuon-lite.",
    "method": "paired_t",
    "seeds": [
      0,
      1,
      2
    ],
    "unit": "training_seed",
    "version": 1
  },
  "eval": {
    "aggregation": "token_mean",
    "benchmark": "no_robots test split (HuggingFaceH4/no_robots, split=test)",
    "metric": "held-out token_mean NLL (nats per assistant loss token)",
    "n_examples": 500
  },
  "experiment_features": {
    "adaptive_selection": true,
    "checkpoint_restore": false,
    "custom_loss": false,
    "custom_optimizer": true,
    "generated_training_data": false,
    "heldout_loss": true,
    "learned_generator": false,
    "paired_comparison": true,
    "paired_training_arms": true,
    "warmup_adaptation": false
  },
  "feasibility": {
    "config": null,
    "downsizing_order": "drop IFEval secondary, then shrink LR grid to 2 points per optimizer, then shorten selection runs to 25 steps; keep 3 seeds and the 100-step test NLL. If that still does not fit, report inconclusive.",
    "effective_config": {
      "arms": 12,
      "base_model": "Qwen/Qwen3.5-2B",
      "batch_size": 32,
      "confirmation_steps": 100,
      "max_seq_len": 2048,
      "n_eval_test": 500,
      "n_eval_validation": 500,
      "n_ifeval_secondary": 541,
      "planned_arm_steps": 840,
      "selection_steps": 40
    },
    "generation": null,
    "measurements": null,
    "primary_endpoint": "no_robots_test_token_mean_nll_at_step_100",
    "recovery": null,
    "source": null
  },
  "feasibility_check": {
    "generation_applicability": {
      "check": "generation_audit",
      "enforce": false,
      "features": {
        "generated_training_data": false
      },
      "reasons": [
        "spec.generation_audit opts out and no feature it covers is true"
      ],
      "status": "not_applicable"
    },
    "generation_counts": null,
    "gpu_hours": null,
    "known_gpu_hours": 0,
    "phases": {},
    "problems": [
      "Effective configuration not recorded",
      "Pilot evidence source not recorded",
      "Representative training timing not recorded",
      "Representative setup timing not recorded",
      "Representative evaluation timing not recorded",
      "Positive recovery reserve not recorded"
    ],
    "status": "unknown",
    "wall_seconds": null
  },
  "feasibility_required": true,
  "generation_audit": {
    "answer_comparison": null,
    "max_eval_overlaps": 0,
    "max_label_errors": 0,
    "min_sample_size": 0,
    "reason": "fixed public dataset; no generated training data",
    "required": false
  },
  "hypothesis": "With per-optimizer learning rates picked on a validation split, LoRA SFT with dimuon-lite cuts held-out no_robots token_mean NLL by at least 0.02 nats versus AdamW. Both arms use the same 100 steps, batches and seeds.",
  "lora_rank": 32,
  "max_seq_len": 2048,
  "method": "Train a rank-32 LoRA on Qwen/Qwen3.5-2B over HuggingFaceH4/no_robots, using one tinker SDK script for both arms so the only difference is the optimizer. The cookbook chat_sl recipe is AdamW-only, so running AdamW through the same script removes any recipe difference. DiMuon is selected at creation with optimizer=tinker.types.DimuonOptimizerConfig() and stepped with DimuonParams(learning_rate, beta1=0.9, grad_clip_norm=0.0). AdamW uses tinker.AdamParams(learning_rate, beta1=0.9, beta2=0.95, eps=1e-8). dimuon-lite is a recently landed reverse-engineered update rule: Polar Express orthogonalization with about 5 iterations, rank_lr_correction_exponent 0.175, Muon on LoRA B, and no beta2. Its update is checked against the trusted DiMuon reconstruction before the comparison runs. Phase 1, LR selection: each optimizer runs 40 steps at seed 0 on a 3-point LR grid fixed now (AdamW {5e-5, 1e-4, 2e-4}; DiMuon {3e-4, 1e-3, 3e-3}). Each run is scored by token_mean NLL on 500 validation items held out from the train split, and the best LR per optimizer is frozen. Phase 2, confirmation: each optimizer trains 100 steps at its frozen LR for seeds {0,1,2}. Batches are identical across arms within a seed: the same shuffled order of the remaining 9,000 train rows, batch_size 32, max_seq_len 2048. Data order and LoRA init seed are shared per seed. Primary eval is token_mean NLL on the full 500-example no_robots test split, computed from per-example summed logprobs times loss weights via forward(). Secondary, descriptive only: IFEval prompt-level strict accuracy (541 prompts, greedy, max_tokens 1024) on each final checkpoint. IFEval is dropped first if feasibility does not fit.",
  "optimizer": {
    "lr": 0.001,
    "name": "dimuon-lite"
  },
  "primary_endpoint": "no_robots_test_token_mean_nll_at_step_100",
  "restoration_preflight": {
    "applicable": true,
    "fixed_batch_required": true,
    "groups": [
      {
        "arms": [
          {
            "name": "baseline_adamw_s0",
            "optimizer": "adam",
            "optimizer_config": {
              "beta1": 0.9,
              "beta2": 0.95,
              "eps": 1e-08,
              "lr": "frozen"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "treatment_dimuon_s0",
            "optimizer": "dimuon-lite",
            "optimizer_config": {
              "beta1": 0.9,
              "grad_clip_norm": 0.0,
              "lr": "frozen"
            }
          }
        ]
      },
      {
        "arms": [
          {
            "name": "baseline_adamw_s1",
            "optimizer": "adam",
            "optimizer_config": {
              "beta1": 0.9,
              "beta2": 0.95,
              "eps": 1e-08,
              "lr": "frozen"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "treatment_dimuon_s1",
            "optimizer": "dimuon-lite",
            "optimizer_config": {
              "beta1": 0.9,
              "grad_clip_norm": 0.0,
              "lr": "frozen"
            }
          }
        ]
      },
      {
        "arms": [
          {
            "name": "baseline_adamw_s2",
            "optimizer": "adam",
            "optimizer_config": {
              "beta1": 0.9,
              "beta2": 0.95,
              "eps": 1e-08,
              "lr": "frozen"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "treatment_dimuon_s2",
            "optimizer": "dimuon-lite",
            "optimizer_config": {
              "beta1": 0.9,
              "grad_clip_norm": 0.0,
              "lr": "frozen"
            }
          }
        ]
      }
    ],
    "reason": "AdamW and DiMuon arms are trained from a shared fresh-LoRA start within each seed. Before the first update, each arm calls save_weights and downloads the adapter. The SHA-256 of the LoRA tensors must match across the paired arms; B=0 at init, and A comes from the seeded init. Base-model logprobs on a fixed tokenized batch must also match. A hash mismatch makes that seed inconclusive. Optimizer type is verified by the activation-gate step-1 spectrum check, not by invented introspection."
  },
  "steps": 100,
  "success_criterion": "Validated if the simultaneous 95% paired_t interval, across 3 training seeds, for (AdamW NLL \u2212 DiMuon NLL) on no_robots test token_mean NLL at step 100 lies entirely above 0.02 nats. Failed if it lies entirely below 0.02. Otherwise inconclusive. IFEval strict accuracy is reported descriptively and does not decide.",
  "title": "dimuon-lite vs AdamW, LoRA SFT on Qwen3.5-2B, no_robots held-out NLL",
  "training_type": "sft"
}

[
  {
    "arm": "baseline_adamw_s0",
    "step": 100,
    "uri": "tinker://f11c48d0f72f37d4ff9c6cde3cf5e327/weights/confirm-baseline_adamw_s0-final"
  },
  {
    "arm": "treatment_dimuon_s0",
    "step": 100,
    "uri": "tinker://5114900d3184a1f9e9047b5305999c3f/weights/confirm-treatment_dimuon_s0-final"
  },
  {
    "arm": "baseline_adamw_s1",
    "step": 100,
    "uri": "tinker://3237e16ec54b87586f4118a972d03f52/weights/confirm-baseline_adamw_s1-final"
  },
  {
    "arm": "treatment_dimuon_s1",
    "step": 100,
    "uri": "tinker://08e25db82a092035669aa384182fbeb0/weights/confirm-treatment_dimuon_s1-final"
  },
  {
    "arm": "baseline_adamw_s2",
    "step": 100,
    "uri": "tinker://8eaad4366b3e3f1193bc20115d07490d/weights/confirm-baseline_adamw_s2-final"
  },
  {
    "arm": "treatment_dimuon_s2",
    "step": 100,
    "uri": "tinker://c8db5bb847cd27aaacea58a0dd7561a8/weights/confirm-treatment_dimuon_s2-final"
  },
  {
    "arm": "sel_adamw_lr5e-05_s0",
    "step": 40,
    "uri": "tinker://3e998640432b43e01b7fb42771192b91/weights/select-sel_adamw_lr5e-05_s0-final"
  },
  {
    "arm": "sel_adamw_lr0.0001_s0",
    "step": 40,
    "uri": "tinker://03adbc7870ed91f79da6f4176f6bc747/weights/select-sel_adamw_lr0.0001_s0-final"
  },
  {
    "arm": "sel_adamw_lr0.0002_s0",
    "step": 40,
    "uri": "tinker://bbaff5449c41db38914ac3f4523738b2/weights/select-sel_adamw_lr0.0002_s0-final"
  },
  {
    "arm": "sel_dimuon_lr0.0003_s0",
    "step": 40,
    "uri": "tinker://df15cdc0afbf74e50388cdfd5d48723d/weights/select-sel_dimuon_lr0.0003_s0-final"
  },
  {
    "arm": "sel_dimuon_lr0.001_s0",
    "step": 40,
    "uri": "tinker://07a741b9c4df208a09f7f0ba7592d096/weights/select-sel_dimuon_lr0.001_s0-final"
  },
  {
    "arm": "sel_dimuon_lr0.003_s0",
    "step": 40,
    "uri": "tinker://c1d1931de8c1fc62d30b56642bd6b4bf/weights/select-sel_dimuon_lr0.003_s0-final"
  }
]

{
  "baseline_adamw_s0": {
    "lr": 0.0002,
    "test_example_mean_nll_step100": 1.91155507915606,
    "test_token_mean_nll_step100": 2.0330861653887684
  },
  "baseline_adamw_s1": {
    "lr": 0.0002,
    "test_example_mean_nll_step100": 1.91241359540049,
    "test_token_mean_nll_step100": 2.0314219380012872
  },
  "baseline_adamw_s2": {
    "lr": 0.0002,
    "test_example_mean_nll_step100": 1.9100704506768729,
    "test_token_mean_nll_step100": 2.030896831835155
  },
  "sel_adamw_lr0.0001_s0": {
    "val_token_mean_nll_step40": 2.0660295206510506
  },
  "sel_adamw_lr0.0002_s0": {
    "val_token_mean_nll_step40": 2.063437024862308
  },
  "sel_adamw_lr5e-05_s0": {
    "val_token_mean_nll_step40": 2.0706937086139385
  },
  "sel_dimuon_lr0.0003_s0": {
    "val_token_mean_nll_step40": 2.2506468688995436
  },
  "sel_dimuon_lr0.001_s0": {
    "val_token_mean_nll_step40": 2.1066402324519578
  },
  "sel_dimuon_lr0.003_s0": {
    "val_token_mean_nll_step40": 2.067498914444817
  },
  "treatment_dimuon_s0": {
    "lr": 0.003,
    "test_example_mean_nll_step100": 1.9114180149242064,
    "test_token_mean_nll_step100": 2.0325384676338447
  },
  "treatment_dimuon_s1": {
    "lr": 0.003,
    "test_example_mean_nll_step100": 1.909182655629596,
    "test_token_mean_nll_step100": 2.030357345510328
  },
  "treatment_dimuon_s2": {
    "lr": 0.003,
    "test_example_mean_nll_step100": 1.9098447542370276,
    "test_token_mean_nll_step100": 2.0305850384881765
  }
}

primary_mean_adamw_minus_dimuon

0.0006414

primary_ci95_low

-0.0003151

primary_ci95_high

0.001598

primary_sd

0.000385

margin

0.02

diff_adamw_minus_dimuon_s0

0.0005477

diff_adamw_minus_dimuon_s1

0.001065

diff_adamw_minus_dimuon_s2

0.0003118

selected_lr_adamw

0.0002

selected_lr_dimuon

0.003

paired_batch_hash_match_confirmation

1

wall_minutes

74.95

trainer_gpu_hours

1.147

• checkpoint · baseline_adamw_s0 · step 100 · tinker://f11c48d0f72f37d4ff9c6cde3cf5e327/weights/confirm-baseline_adamw_s0-final
• checkpoint · treatment_dimuon_s0 · step 100 · tinker://5114900d3184a1f9e9047b5305999c3f/weights/confirm-treatment_dimuon_s0-final
• checkpoint · baseline_adamw_s1 · step 100 · tinker://3237e16ec54b87586f4118a972d03f52/weights/confirm-baseline_adamw_s1-final
• checkpoint · treatment_dimuon_s1 · step 100 · tinker://08e25db82a092035669aa384182fbeb0/weights/confirm-treatment_dimuon_s1-final
• checkpoint · baseline_adamw_s2 · step 100 · tinker://8eaad4366b3e3f1193bc20115d07490d/weights/confirm-baseline_adamw_s2-final
• checkpoint · treatment_dimuon_s2 · step 100 · tinker://c8db5bb847cd27aaacea58a0dd7561a8/weights/confirm-treatment_dimuon_s2-final
• checkpoint · sel_adamw_lr5e-05_s0 · step 40 · tinker://3e998640432b43e01b7fb42771192b91/weights/select-sel_adamw_lr5e-05_s0-final
• checkpoint · sel_adamw_lr0.0001_s0 · step 40 · tinker://03adbc7870ed91f79da6f4176f6bc747/weights/select-sel_adamw_lr0.0001_s0-final
• checkpoint · sel_adamw_lr0.0002_s0 · step 40 · tinker://bbaff5449c41db38914ac3f4523738b2/weights/select-sel_adamw_lr0.0002_s0-final
• checkpoint · sel_dimuon_lr0.0003_s0 · step 40 · tinker://df15cdc0afbf74e50388cdfd5d48723d/weights/select-sel_dimuon_lr0.0003_s0-final
• checkpoint · sel_dimuon_lr0.001_s0 · step 40 · tinker://07a741b9c4df208a09f7f0ba7592d096/weights/select-sel_dimuon_lr0.001_s0-final
• checkpoint · sel_dimuon_lr0.003_s0 · step 40 · tinker://c1d1931de8c1fc62d30b56642bd6b4bf/weights/select-sel_dimuon_lr0.003_s0-final
• script · run.py sha256 8480b967ec29
• script · common.py sha256 531860b23c60
• script · fork_config.py sha256 dfd0ccd95ebc
• script · probe_shared.py sha256 20499f5b52d3
• script · smoke.py sha256 37ac8a8dd697
• script · preflight.py sha256 466afac60991
• script · analyze_preflight.py sha256 4574d9d3d7c5
• script · analyze2.py sha256 abf7fc94170c
• script · local_parity.py sha256 9c79b2ed02ff
• script · loadlib.py sha256 ba2b24b2f8c0
• script · build_preflight.py sha256 708c79dd01bb
• script · launch_confirm.py sha256 0b448f42bedd
• script · restore_check.py sha256 995a05bc7fcf
• script · final_analysis.py sha256 a0eb6a3e00fe
• script · loss_eval.py sha256 5e7dd8833027
• script · loss_report.py sha256 ea3cff27bdec
• script · build_result.py sha256 0d045f274dd0
• script · dimuon_candidate.py sha256 31c5f60cb273
• instructions · launch-instructions.md sha256 dfb05d79fc61
• effective_config · effective-config.json sha256 1d9e8504b61c
• code_revision · code-revision.txt sha256 fea50584124d
• code_patch · spindle_fork.patch sha256 e99d856d7c3d
• predictions · predictions-confirm-test.jsonl sha256 3657247fd14a
• metrics · scored-observations-final.jsonl sha256 90d81ba7953f
• metrics · select_log.jsonl sha256 f47284b8fc80
• metrics · confirm_log.jsonl sha256 bdf2f3591091
• metrics · pilot_log.jsonl sha256 0755d8e73d3c
• metrics · preflight_log.json sha256 8d4fdf3ece72
• metrics · probe_shared_log.json sha256 71b2ba23dad9
• metrics · correctness_preflight.json sha256 7cc662748d8f
• metrics · preflight_results.json sha256 2feb6fdd919a
• metrics · local_parity.json sha256 51ce08e44345
• metrics · restore_check.json sha256 354a2d0e9cbe
• metrics · selection_frozen.json sha256 ce8a7eaad120
• metrics · final_numbers.json sha256 5f319af65221
• metrics · loss_eval_record.json sha256 2830948954bc
• metrics · spec.json sha256 88d9223c010d

1. Nov 4, 16:21 UTC · succeeded · done: sel_adamw_lr5e-05_s0, sel_adamw_lr0.0001_s0, sel_adamw_lr0.0002_s0, sel_dimuon_lr0.0003_s0, sel_dimuon_lr0.001_s0, sel_dimuon_lr0.003_s0, baseline_adamw_s0, treatment_dimuon_s0, baseline_adamw_s1, treatment_dimuon_s1, baseline_adamw_s2, treatment_dimuon_s2 · On fork spindle-fork-run_07e69074dc, 100-step rank-32 LoRA SFT of Qwen3.5-2B on no_robots gave AdamW-minus-Dimuon test token-mean NLL +0.00064 nats (per-seed +0.00055, +0.00106, +0.00031; 95% paired-…
2. Nov 4, 15:39 UTC · running · Fork spindle-fork-run_07e69074dc deployed (shared Spindle rejects dimuon). Correctness preflight: AdamW parity pass, identical-input Dimuon-vs-reference parity exact, LR scaling pass; restore-replay …
3. Nov 4, 15:19 UTC · running · Shared Spindle rejects dimuon (400 'optimizer family dimuon is not supported'); AdamW works. Deployed throwaway fork spindle-fork-run_07e69074dc in research-exchange-runs (Spindle 5148cb6 + proxy-aut…
4. Nov 4, 15:10 UTC · running · Launch instructions downloaded and hash-verified; setting up shared-Spindle optimizer probe and Spindle fork for dimuon-lite.

correctness_preflight

{'required': True, 'paths': [{'id': 'spindle_dimuon_lite_optimizer', 'fixed_input': {'sha256': '531ee9d8f612c6223ce02e0ec63ec5302de9b8c591d90c84ce6e1d29f923f845', 'description': 'Step-1 fixture: seed-0 first no_robots train batch (32 seqs, sha256 d9ce572e4cf770c21e54e31f0cd523d578343475316b862f1453171ae1c3c6eb, cross_entropy, cookbook weights), fork init state tinker://accb828dfecae1fa66fdd1a5cd641b23/weights/pf-init (fp32 sha256 3388743efeef0e9eb77f61bc1fc018db7bb82e5e6a313f707ad028d9b95e1bd0, LoRA B=0), optimizer state reset per client. Hash covers the exact fp32 gradient fixture (AdamW client exp_avg). Stale-scale step 2 uses a second fixed fp32 gradient. Retrieved via modal volume get run_07e69074dc-checkpoints.'}, 'baseline_revision': 'UNRESOLVED: pin the modal-projects/spindle commit deployed at the shared Spindle URL (post-#85). AdamW updates on this deployment must match the pre-#85 AdamW update on identical grads/state.', 'reference_revision': "UNRESOLVED: pin the commit of Aaron's DiMuon reconstruction (0.09% relative update error vs Tinker) and the modal-projects/miles commit of #17", 'resolved_revisions': {'baseline_executed': 'fork spindle-fork-run_07e69074dc: modal-projects/spindle 5148cb62a019862ef9b50d76b7be55cddb288e8a (PR #85 branch claude/dimuon-spindle-wiring) + spindle_fork.patch (requires_proxy_auth=True); shared Spindle deployment 4af4dd2c46c009fcf8661e625195d4bf6c5dde81 is pre-#85 (rejects dimuon), so no post-#85 shared deployment exists. AdamW reference = stock torch.optim.AdamW on identical exp_avg-derived gradient and init.', 'reference_executed': "Aaron's DiMuon reconstruction has no git commit; pinned by content sha256 31c5f60cb273ca53a0adfda9b88b8ff8fd1efd05c497114dbd0cb1f99673c51e (dimuon_candidate.py, code block of Notion page 3fe1e7f169498132903de1b12bfe4205). Miles PR #17 = modal-projects/miles 228b59d90074e6cec48090e033202c5a4aff3ff3 (dimuon.py sha256 8c5268543094cc6677a4606ecbd5902749c34a5e2f95fa7ba29890e732e86519), mounted via SPINDLE_MILES_TREE."}, 'implementation_revision': 'spindle 5148cb62a019862ef9b50d76b7be55cddb288e8a+proxy-auth patch; miles 228b59d90074e6cec48090e033202c5a4aff3ff3 (dimuon.py sha256 8c5268543094cc6677a4606ecbd5902749c34a5e2f95fa7ba29890e732e86519)', 'precision': 'fp32 master params and gradients; Dimuon working momentum fp32, persisted momentum bf16, Polar Express 5 iters horner_fp16; AdamW fp32 exp_avg/exp_avg_sq; model forward/backward bf16', 'normalization': 'cross_entropy sum of weighted token NLL (cookbook weights, counted by weight>0); Dimuon per-projection-block direction scaled to Frobenius sqrt(rank=32), update lr*(32/32)^0.175, damping 1e-4, beta1 0.9, no grad clip; AdamW bias-corrected first step lr*m_hat/(sqrt(v_hat)+1e-8)', 'errors': {'baseline_update': {'max_abs_error': 2.9103830456733704e-11, 'reference_max_abs': 0.00010000001202570274, 'relative_l2_error': 1.1836754552721225e-07, 'cosine_similarity': 0.9999999999984532}, 'reference_update': {'max_abs_error': 0.0, 'reference_max_abs': 0.00043169609853066504, 'relative_l2_error': 0.0, 'cosine_similarity': 0.999999999999538}}, 'diagnostic_errors': {'reference_update_stale_scales_step2_packed_vs_unpacked': {'max_abs_error': 5.820766091346741e-11, 'reference_max_abs': 0.00045147983473725617, 'relative_l2_error': 7.76425975758586e-08, 'cosine_similarity': 1.0000000000056577}, 'server_dimuon_vs_reference_bf16_momentum_reconstructed_grad': {'max_abs_error': 1.6289202903863043e-05, 'reference_max_abs': 0.00043122234637849033, 'relative_l2_error': 0.008891037556287004, 'cosine_similarity': 0.9999604746790172}, 'server_dimuon_vs_local_miles_same_bf16_input': {'max_abs_error': 1.6289202903863043e-05, 'reference_max_abs': 0.00043122234637849033, 'relative_l2_error': 0.008891037556287004, 'cosine_similarity': 0.99996047467902}, 'server_dimuon_vs_reference_other_client_fp32_grad': {'max_abs_error': 1.6678692190907896e-05, 'reference_max_abs': 0.00043169609853066504, 'relative_l2_error': 0.011249974322777249, 'cosine_similarity': 0.999936718962419}, 'server_cross_client_noise_floor_lr1e-4x10_vs_lr1e-3': {'max_abs_error': 1.5426019672304392e-05, 'reference_max_abs': 0.0004318455175962299, 'relative_l2_error': 0.008530711051707019, 'cosine_similarity': 0.9999636134824236}, 'server_cross_client_gradient_agreement': {'max_abs_error': 0.0039064884185791016, 'reference_max_abs': 0.9726564288139344, 'relative_l2_error': 0.004391774377892753, 'cosine_similarity': 0.9999903569331032}, 'restore_replay_update_vs_uninterrupted': {'max_abs_error': 4.352768883109093e-05, 'reference_max_abs': 0.0004933822783641517, 'relative_l2_error': 0.009953487697234082, 'cosine_similarity': 0.9999504640550458}}, 'reference_update_note': "errors.reference_update compares the deployed Miles Dimuon code against Aaron's reference on bitwise-identical fp32 inputs (passes). Server-executed update vs reference (measured this run): with bf16-persisted momentum as input max_abs 1.63e-05, cosine 0.999960, 6 of 27475968 elements outside atol 1e-5/rtol 1e-2; with another client's fp32 gradient max_abs 1.67e-05, 6 elements outside. Create-save-restore replay vs uninterrupted step 2: rel L2 0.0100, cosine 0.999950, 83 elements outside atol 1e-5/rtol 1e-2 (attributed, not proven, to bf16 optimizer-state persistence; no arm restores optimizer state mid-training).", 'lr_scaling': [{'learning_rate': 0.0001, 'update_norm': 0.005571355029109937}, {'learning_rate': 0.001, 'update_norm': 0.05571355460103725}, {'learning_rate': 0.01, 'update_norm': 0.5571355024069835}], 'restore_replay_update_vs_uninterrupted': {'max_abs_error': 4.352768883109093e-05, 'reference_max_abs': 0.0004933822783641517, 'relative_l2_error': 0.009953487697234082, 'cosine_similarity': 0.9999504640550458, 'elementwise_pass_fraction': 0.9999969791783132, 'n_elements': 27475968, 'n_fail': 83}, 'restore_replay_momentum': {'max_abs_error': 0.00048828125, 'reference_max_abs': 0.1787109375, 'relative_l2_error': 0.00342291724776035, 'cosine_similarity': 0.9999941420738796}}]}

correctness_validation

{'status': 'passed', 'required': True, 'checks': [{'path': 'spindle_dimuon_lite_optimizer', 'check': 'baseline_update', 'status': 'passed', 'tolerance': {'atol': 1e-06, 'rtol': 0.001, 'min_cosine': 0.99999}, 'measured': {'max_abs_error': 2.9103830456733704e-11, 'reference_max_abs': 0.00010000001202570274, 'relative_l2_error': 1.1836754552721225e-07, 'cosine_similarity': 0.9999999999984532}}, {'path': 'spindle_dimuon_lite_optimizer', 'check': 'reference_update', 'status': 'passed', 'tolerance': {'atol': 1e-05, 'rtol': 0.01, 'min_cosine': 0.999}, 'measured': {'max_abs_error': 0.0, 'reference_max_abs': 0.00043169609853066504, 'relative_l2_error': 0.0, 'cosine_similarity': 0.999999999999538}}, {'path': 'spindle_dimuon_lite_optimizer', 'check': 'lr_scaling', 'status': 'passed', 'relative_error': 7.735888063464813e-08, 'tolerance': {'learning_rates': [0.0001, 0.001, 0.01], 'rtol': 0.01}}], 'reason': 'Reported baseline and reference parity checks meet accepted tolerances.', 'evidence_source': 'executor report; remote execution is not attested', 'applicability': 'required', 'reported_verdict': 'refuted'}

decision

{'version': 1, 'observations_file': {'name': 'scored-observations-final.jsonl', 'sha256': '90d81ba7953febfbf87cb9cf424dc0180f026e1d67a5d04b323b0d026da73f56'}, 'selection': {'frozen_before_confirmation': True, 'selection_split': '500 held-out no_robots train rows (Random(1234) shuffle, first 500), disjoint from training and test rows', 'selection_steps': 40, 'adamw': {'scores': {'5e-05': 2.0706937086139385, '0.0001': 2.0660295206510506, '0.0002': 2.063437024862308}, 'selected_lr': 0.0002, 'edge': True}, 'dimuon': {'scores': {'0.0003': 2.2506468688995436, '0.001': 2.1066402324519578, '0.003': 2.067498914444817}, 'selected_lr': 0.003, 'edge': True}, 'grid_edge_selected': True}}

decision_validation

{'status': 'uncertain', 'issues': ['Adaptive selection requires disjoint search and confirmation IDs.'], 'criteria': [], 'outcome_reason': 'insufficient_evidence', 'observations_file': {'name': 'scored-observations-final.jsonl', 'sha256': '90d81ba7953febfbf87cb9cf424dc0180f026e1d67a5d04b323b0d026da73f56', 'size': 1501, 'n_observations': 6}, 'unit': 'training_seed', 'n_seeds': 3, 'alpha': 0.05, 'method': 'paired_t', 'assumptions': {'independent_seed_effects': True, 'identically_distributed_seed_effects': True, 'normal_seed_effects': True}, 'applicability': {'check': 'decision_rule', 'status': 'required', 'enforce': True, 'reasons': ['experiment_features: paired_comparison, adaptive_selection is true'], 'features': {'paired_comparison': True, 'adaptive_selection': True}}, 'reported_verdict': 'refuted'}

evaluation

{'version': 1, 'evaluators': {'830529b5110015d8cccda36ffa0fcf180860e8176a1c44e71da3544beaa48c16': {'code_sha256': 'ffd3004c90297bfdb8c5c39aa53f1e94d2ff8769ee6fc23c2ac35b956692733c', 'prompt_template': 'tinker_cookbook renderer for Qwen/Qwen3.5-2B (renderers.get_recommended_renderer_name), conversation_to_datum(messages, renderer, max_length=2048), TrainOnWhat=ALL_ASSISTANT_MESSAGES default; teacher-forced cross_entropy forward; NLL counted where weight>0', 'decoding': {'type': 'teacher_forced_forward', 'temperature': None, 'max_tokens': 0, 'stop': []}, 'parser': 'token NLL = -sum(logprobs[weights>0]); token_mean = sum NLL / sum counted tokens over 500 items', 'items': {'ids': ['no_robots_test:d6c011ffb1ff8a9abe9bd24caf3f9817454a1f054d5d0e0360d19bf50cf6b20c', 'no_robots_test:7682c850c4e5979cef0ad966b8feb119de2bd323bb40819767a161040b59eb7a', 'no_robots_test:45971bbe382b81644487690d2018bc3aec8c807f1be52a9744223e5492255928', 'no_robots_test:ccdce774f24ede2e799686276e8b72e8b08a4aebf6ba75ecc450fc73cfedd1a8', 'no_robots_test:c1f40447167a99977d745672c0c19cb2739b6f5208647af47fac16c94f88826e', 'no_robots_test:f7128731ae16e9ccfbb888620c5d75564fb8d12350e9b47c781beeb64ebd04c7', 'no_robots_test:f865f7581ddc128be8b79fa82e7fa9102362b6a7685d82f9116436280073695b', 'no_robots_test:2e26a31997285dc001e683aec269ec9b0c4e3400b97a7cbb6367a08e374dfedc', 'no_robots_test:3fad3d579a7259e0bbff20c18d4c72049a7b9378078c85188ba9b166216b4775', 'no_robots_test:cc614a388398a30b28e3b18b9382a1438d8b8455377d6a65f902a709a75168a1', 'no_robots_test:e038c9bbc2ec4556f6ab47f9651fa89cb5d7f72891a5fba4415e13f18f7ca0b7', 'no_robots_test:37746cac882d406894272569214f6ede6ab7b78de88c01e6bea144234a4013bf', 'no_robots_test:6ac710f1196bc72404d3e08e8acca16f7f144752544aa4af9a19736053fbda4b', 'no_robots_test:f52ce291ce39c76f22e3771a091d24bb55b3831106506a3835c2a2e16a86d1c1', 'no_robots_test:5a5c6035044f914d24e5fa5677048b7461bb3c3a4a7cfa474fbcfa29588670d8', 'no_robots_test:c1c9a958b19539efc3ce03adb85c0c7811393e90d35f33f4d96e999d79e3e8a9', 'no_robots_test:66e33c21f54193775c1fda86f9be739152462cea267969b838ed953956f4b631', 'no_robots_test:3c338b2227c9f2922a94c730fc653d50dec826ea0febb228867efb3709a3f31d', 'no_robots_test:85b810a2c52be481e2f79b741fb8a02142c18d9db329189689789240bad537a6', 'no_robots_test:ba7cd3cea48952cd4f218fb4ba23a7a0d9f6d3e2b524eb897a063d567521bcbc', 'no_robots_test:645c6de54016df90ea64d9b72a1686de2c682467cc0988ed2b8379e4af3a3b69', 'no_robots_test:ba474c32c7c4db657376ec72136594729848d88a0423d0457e9f6eea6680e9c1', 'no_robots_test:ebd302ba966ef926516b751f9d42bd52ed4b21747f424f147c33de05d5cb46a5', 'no_robots_test:d555a1b6eab48b9f199186e30b6b691eafd4b0df80a6558b64c4c5d60509848a', 'no_robots_test:1329aaafcece6e6674ee78a546492be7047a72bd8eed93a15490b517d195f8aa', 'no_robots_test:ca2aefe6159c88ab4335e1b2a19e04bb70d2d096c8b6487946607a4fb57b9207', 'no_robots_test:f8385c2bedf5af812b3e13ed50abf373552e551992c637acf8c341fb2bd4ef30', 'no_robots_test:687e88746b34ab7a856e2d8795eb696de02b6909f8e68dd0c5595cf754eb22b2', 'no_robots_test:b096cd3cc576e1df1bfc3ea2e8c1b89817a67e1f4d4209100e7e0ac03323b45a', 'no_robots_test:503c617fbdab4576be1c79b421947a7c5f1a2b365808c6b6f8e31287d1aeb674', 'no_robots_test:46ffb831bbb5717977280909d133272c1cda68f7769a58f18e83331e906c5aa0', 'no_robots_test:d155ad5a56b452703abf0c54969f8cfd0372dcbe0befcd4a0af5a0fbdcbfe23b', 'no_robots_test:d36d2dcd016969972e6ea69b0ad14f9ff2b6e341d9ff7565318d6082b0523ba6', 'no_robots_test:9d2c280bd301ce2066b71f70cdfe03494262cf4f369010aea6e00f23f853cbc7', 'no_robots_test:37ac631bf0d66b95a69519e58da6a3c4f1118d6960bace298e83087805422076', 'no_robots_test:91e0052f1664f2e28d66653914c81a87f27e0b24a46b9136e4748a8c24545289', 'no_robots_test:6f921864bd8b8123377fe29446547b0cfccf9882bda00e1ed0a11f99c7290799', 'no_robots_test:06f8cec4f3a7a51087180e3fba0d8a2c19c0866cff613bbc7d044033f82467e5', 'no_robots_test:41d3a40c684db02d115771774e75f6812745b96bfc8b26c6198f3537fa5bd7e8', 'no_robots_test:71b63a042ad1e85efc91ec2ac3a88629d29d13978696515b1bc0d29bea1fae36', 'no_robots_test:40f8e6e855826d7d7671f4dbb5f7c12ae99541888fe78e7b4d669adbe00b1151', 'no_robots_test:0869a2536bae18939b4f62b6c026f631cc44083e1903bde4de0b1e7e339702e5', 'no_robots_test:ac80dd9713747a25db3164ad15d37c61409a02257bd88433e1c254eb927a4372', 'no_robots_test:2fb3649c9d992e39a4a394aeb16b91720ec8ae19dd43895b3914a6511144ca1e', 'no_robots_test:bb96ffd53f0444b90e6fad698788ab9ccd24d6f63aa674494be21315ee7a2dd3', 'no_robots_test:2beadd667769f5875ab256f7f840e2c6d26c1b667ba4ef11d814b61153da6e13', 'no_robots_test:a9a8696c28ade7a3f9e0b3d8d97abb862ed987239887e988a2dd21cee1915cb2', 'no_robots_test:bab1283b2cfd37eb5a264da47f0663cea09d18088cd4c48886d0174e1eba536e', 'no_robots_test:b3b45db4ac4b90ae5fddacef19c5deb1a91dbee65068d9ab0d36d3e1aa92334b', 'no_robots_test:c2596826a823a13939db48d0ee04bfb0083fdf8133eff4468550ca63ebb76864', 'no_robots_test:069a404880fd7eebecec2132e04406f2858b71a7588237de0c546d826aa2cce3', 'no_robots_test:151659a113f8a967eea7c23e19e96b0da262f736a3560b9dff28efb68b553978', 'no_robots_test:0f861d5aa34b0dcfc2ddd35da09fc581aff25b042a2795f36bda290e00071378', 'no_robots_test:498c6846aff34679bd2acaf9a40672c60df6dc00e30ecd2be181b233b23faf1e', 'no_robots_test:3a2e37c1fe2d7c63b55330af7098035b4dc8142da2ff249f35820cd06b458cea', 'no_robots_test:c97be73986b86b7bb444ba1402ece81e49a0e962be40a66a0021c293d0e48134', 'no_robots_test:371d8db9eaa9687270ad0fab91513225fa7ce1c54e5a0d845f126a7ae386e735', 'no_robots_test:2d0ff0f26fb8e8effcd4918c0653fcc0eee53226f4d13b79eee2fc03df6286aa', 'no_robots_test:ad3ade87b53d6f4adc940e6f4ba711e65b73e7d2fc4a2aa4e15c0b733b110b29', 'no_robots_test:716e64d1f2292720df26399fee0aaf5e015009178041a6ec8fedc17e2d9e9df6', 'no_robots_test:569e694f8ad2b83ae1e997fd4b19849b0859d23873a4147bb31e7873ed29e086', 'no_robots_test:3956cffb3efd15358c82ae59c24fdcbd58112173f6ff3f8c41888e6c4ed6c895', 'no_robots_test:11cb75d074a4a74b12c17ea021dfe17d72909661a28ca255e000d86573e52f4a', 'no_robots_test:7b69321f3a4e585a40ceba48e7b63685452a123e2cb64486ae5c54ffd3be0d23', 'no_robots_test:ede0754a2e1b91497d9e4db2320edbb495c071f190098537eee95929972e17d1', 'no_robots_test:66ada4a1b1b49410c7f8a6a27934b65139499a9c3e5c65549375068a70a3c51f', 'no_robots_test:02c4f02245b627721c8a03184b85e95b2d7a2a3e2757fcaa53a3f227785f0277', 'no_robots_test:2891116ede1751ddb26aaa9de499dc1149851f957873abcf2903132c62addab8', 'no_robots_test:dc009733b4090c99c626a0b657377e2c3db4dc065ca522659356d8be020a4bdd', 'no_robots_test:252b2127915bf0a3c04b2aa0e9cda42302f94b5feded11ae4d272b4d6d585c30', 'no_robots_test:757b00e4f2279890ebb97605a867e4309c29fce4ddfd2035ff568c7be0bb6b6d', 'no_robots_test:2ce87bfc5c427f720cb5f28f4099db60307f1ed844c4c8e61f1f046e06265fbd', 'no_robots_test:2526b13cafe55ba808ebe720cc2ebfce41f9e0a12b7512ffe6dbf7eb41a559c5', 'no_robots_test:4d0fa72d19e14c4e11a471ab3f0127fbaeee061a5ee6cc5ecf87142920bd0c24', 'no_robots_test:d04ddb39eff5469b4b4b6d090b51e6f46e47dc4daec06702964c1f737f7e8123', 'no_robots_test:525e28a56ceec00670ad602d6553ffdf08501e8a0ca7ea10027a2136bf135d54', 'no_robots_test:a1415ff2282982ef44abfbbecf0503e4d6f0ea6186824ae56e2d438fb3fca23b', 'no_robots_test:9ab2002a593fbbebdc2d4f4678bd21f8d4cd02cd15d65589c403319c8b5f4747', 'no_robots_test:45678c64b9b9861841bb742e8e05cc4c421d21c9bf4dcdf637a96e827c661830', 'no_robots_test:12751be5580238e093aab282dc8b994353b4c0643fae38656978e34fcab15b3e', 'no_robots_test:412c1c7294d8b1d07ab2e23cc6e748d4f9e3ab6628ae1df5ab42c56c7414531e', 'no_robots_test:a8395735b43fc5000483fbf3bb2662975b3ebe5bd83fad730c12cdf6404a41c1', 'no_robots_test:7be45ddf4361ed9d86fc499ee2d6aa4174d7c5aa6db5cd799eec4d789aa9c838', 'no_robots_test:b4ac421b07dd3cf8535f88666150b33d008b709eee6a0281f8b3d01d77e61b42', 'no_robots_test:4d4f7a00621e23c1ef1e1ca6970dda6157a4a7afb000de94fc94163a6406f48c', 'no_robots_test:c4c48bb83330aaf49d90f0673248fb903b29f16adad3efc331c17dd200202483', 'no_robots_test:8c2b9b8240c2ce74726a939bf4c485b9fc3e7868c2f0e48a6a8489659a92168e', 'no_robots_test:8c034a519e1533a7d544faf79099055f5b04c1207f6fbe265e4463dda40e0824', 'no_robots_test:2f9354b6c63a3e550fbab16210d0d38fad27dadba62d375b4f35722a0a46c887', 'no_robots_test:1af4443ea535d2f85009c7705db3081bfa675eda1ffcb4de92ac70102fe23448', 'no_robots_test:8e4228fe80ce2c4c988f5c0a8c60d9672e46566e4f6fe05315a2c5e1f09dc990', 'no_robots_test:b3a1e4ed83a6227f5050917a7059aa210538961b47c678f11fa33b2535467cf4', 'no_robots_test:6936a6d57488b9b79a55bd677f2c130f3c36ba2dc348747826d0f3a5cb5b7027', 'no_robots_test:a1d57c8b8a4d920e196c48e429468a951ee9125c447890b4d891ea3755f1dbd8', 'no_robots_test:21bf1e34609a84aa6f41b73a534567fba26b13d5025844ef1ed9851ff3c35eda', 'no_robots_test:c5bec6d10044644190ba466977bdab9375264adaae2d0c377ffa48410063fc80', 'no_robots_test:798b01c27b9d7d5719cf411a678312f9676dc3845c4b6d3e99744b5d80c4dd6f', 'no_robots_test:6ee94a135df17071b4b0c1f9e7f5ecddaaddd34b568a29642650c851a2def94c', 'no_robots_test:e0eec4940165bbe26d1f4fcf7801fbc2578618f78dd649ab5a1f97258f7ff742', 'no_robots_test:f39be8cff1abe33986b52a7e7aec5a1b8adf9552746697e972812e7babaf3b22', 'no_robots_test:b72a4b2add1b1711109547a75c5318b94db761dc3cd2c08e73e11cfe14469e96', 'no_robots_test:8e0ebb53a5dd1feafa657b34f39e15bfa8913e56f21d61542f7c1932da440426', 'no_robots_test:1ecc678e8184e4ef5150ad3a51b05a3d29fc3b2672e74ff0fb98cc7249ce5883', 'no_robots_test:703d0b37f6b9cc517692f8bcdec6988d82d20e9023b95c901225d206fcd7e5af', 'no_robots_test:eb4fee5c685b36bffcd84b2c68db01fe4842302c24190e144f391b7016bb2330', 'no_robots_test:7954bc81cf750c36c91d432a844a5f2ba689213263761bdebf866d28b3662f61', 'no_robots_test:4f25dfe951a9ee72613ab2e8021ffb4e09871143628991c5fb560e0a3f8a3c67', 'no_robots_test:b8c5dc22944151efd9e6642639973e1ca401e1a380fc0ff4d57a3b24a3173278', 'no_robots_test:979520d6745fc9319044c901dbee403a6dcf48d253e710fb6db78dada2bf712a', 'no_robots_test:47c6604c9b3b4e350ad5f546aa6f4748b59ef6275b4cc4ab99425518b2c7fd3f', 'no_robots_test:d29b4a6069a7d535d79c44dcaacbe6d6f30289086ce2ace4897202dce919811a', 'no_robots_test:f60bb67e4cb1d3dc680b634ea4bf50b3148231fb6e8cfea09aab9c0860eaf63e', 'no_robots_test:4cb56274ed302cc7e7bb9f57bb3d7fe43df6265c6e226cd9fb2f6fd8287eec3e', 'no_robots_test:86ad87691e5725d33d686118811d13876d192cf7525fb83c9e2434ee6d71be56', 'no_robots_test:08d888907bbbb7d371248e13dab35000d0d971f1bd16112e732546226f0802cd', 'no_robots_test:757ed7e67d03ef845a4dcb8b90666504e6bd4e14b2a3c5d954372e14ee5d9aec', 'no_robots_test:290e88a34d533c83aa725c61b56a3f01f0b55db15ba6b332c4432f14634a9fe0', 'no_robots_test:3d701bcf2811e91950d7766cdbd2660e2ee02be6825f8e5dbd569752cb7327b2', 'no_robots_test:bc90d0b2dd1afcddd8de7b2e7ff4d4c770018190ad63c0d1de27cd6c0c046979', 'no_robots_test:ef52784af72fdcb475ca17d2f444011bf89a4f73cba3627ef7a4a369a3dd39f4', 'no_robots_test:2e7da2610042433c41b02cad24401c5c0f83bee93ed07d6f5807f7883d252c45', 'no_robots_test:7f77538b92b924595ccd388f371d085841f926b3f436c964e0d94383ed97b780', 'no_robots_test:076473b02f7f76619fb48bedc3a6295a3be8333d87f67983f0f05dd6f95fa7a0', 'no_robots_test:7e8135ad15dc03710f78522d402a5b8d724706a1ba0445714a448e59a77c2ec9', 'no_robots_test:3391c058e714734b2a349e66d6708733ff35e49cb4d22a521ae0b692e21a76e6', 'no_robots_test:4bdf2305eb042d59d61126bd3018e2a216c7e46b98ba4d8be57f5ad86b82734c', 'no_robots_test:cc1646d3f0fd7b1a8ba246dae952929e522158f26e0524b6f40126b68b34ec8b', 'no_robots_test:0bfc23e86d05103d10342d234b31fe3613b93e7620e6c272b2687e08bfb9491e', 'no_robots_test:dad92f898cd3f957f6a61c8dbbd70cfb6a5aee938edfc0b54af4f8ebdef4bb3c', 'no_robots_test:51217435894e5a1bf8d0e87cfd74e24cbfff862a1f7a39d08596bfbe2c499d32', 'no_robots_test:f5cc15a138584ced005ec845f5a40212cd1e4c389aaadb5db442b61637320d19', 'no_robots_test:aef43863df74ba98f55bbf32bc780175e667b8af13b9308d6e54a35e1efb09bc', 'no_robots_test:d9b5aaf8fb1c656a71df74fc73f1ac3b5e5d63810f5556295f1292cfe00bb87d', 'no_robots_test:02ae13c831902dfa4f7aea6e89bb478d9a64e62c9cd1562334a614e35b62a483', 'no_robots_test:4ec9bf682c8a288c825f56766b2743be9d768c12368980d81715ec0a9a293dbd', 'no_robots_test:6c7f04a463f203983dcfc1b50cd819500d6d0e087c2e746c76714689567e19e7', 'no_robots_test:1fa6007d33362ffd33bb07cb575d3286ae410da730da8f4d6e523d84be1a2332', 'no_robots_test:f7dfc75f57c1c9022920cf1c26cb513280cb76c7d04d604ebdbd2ee95d04218c', 'no_robots_test:95ab39c44458ecc1e254c4d2194c59d86dd455c7dbdec58797b2fcac0f7df839', 'no_robots_test:d1c191631ff3e1bc89519fccf379faf48b2950d3960818b9d86fa7cbb36efb8b', 'no_robots_test:2880e6d3dc46901576c9ff3bc55a3a1a950a0e2bf8a32606c51282995b7e9364', 'no_robots_test:96a2891220d97cc3c1baca4ddf13121f17adbb908b72caf6e946e982d86fefe1', 'no_robots_test:068f53051dcc214ec91622949ac1d49db7d3c6eb0e885172fb93513e45d883e0', 'no_robots_test:5a6f31d9ba234bfecceee2b6db822077c30aa23d2dd40602fc94663bda4e1cd9', 'no_robots_test:2830c95d42887be796a6c5e0cc1de1d29619cc4f33ecf1f2e0fd7b7319b041e2', 'no_robots_test:4d06ff6439f54b7345b83b8bed2e689493104c9338efc5e21243ade63cabd1f7', 'no_robots_test:326a5c2c6bbd8459c6e1edf67b56da08d0bbe39d1ee02dcf7dcb13518b9d44d6', 'no_robots_test:a0cb5111b8e2d4fe6560ae67761862ab2e5608410668e0ea382bd68defff5d10', 'no_robots_test:f2fb01116f39477efc5e0e8ab47809920621d6c74e9a4a60ec9aa1c7c8201410', 'no_robots_test:2e24e4d095b5bb0dbcd738f61cb9a783c121ac44188937c846c800c4eca2fe60', 'no_robots_test:967305b1921daa495ef581fdc52997046809ecc01ed6ca818f4c52c085c3dd2c', 'no_robots_test:fd80e71474ab525762acf1d979f85ecb5a6fe83d34087d7baac7f108e31b4415', 'no_robots_test:c421a5055d01c12bf1ca46211b65dd34e67d5111d502cce455d1e3e10dcd1c48', 'no_robots_test:1789df91903365b9016e4015a62c0771379d0f6b1c12cde49c00deafd16e568b', 'no_robots_test:d097f9337d9beae903165700e60c8107fdd5f4dbdcdeb718ff5ab38bde15460b', 'no_robots_test:3b2803a605e122e0ab8e6626269ba570c29249d45ba58d7a54b63a7e0f97e5bc', 'no_robots_test:89e44a65181076ab721592e13a69c971d9f067eb21db9a11468ed41430dadd2d', 'no_robots_test:95c8a688253b51b33e956f0f62e143ba558a3494da559d8d35ea0ad544885ead', 'no_robots_test:9d5e4c39e16efdc6470e674ed1523697946b836509ad4965c47726cc8f6cb6df', 'no_robots_test:4d3216e0e9c5525fd3ff1b390fe9ddfe994eda332607d0fdb4986b19877dc6c0', 'no_robots_test:eaea0c1080796440180027b3ddca45c68eca17d3b2070f65b50ff67b6393352f', 'no_robots_test:213eb243af6ec6084438ae97c83acc1224eb51d005da0de0735b6eebbfa523c3', 'no_robots_test:45242f3a7707cd505500f1026ea4840d01c833047ca5b677ce90ae7e029dcbdc', 'no_robots_test:f119ab42649b334ed54181aa9d9e198678502b7f309a7f1b8021200ad43c7131', 'no_robots_test:ec0ab0abc0cd6b428980887f7fdb6fdc36eae28ed284b484af3007a36aede555', 'no_robots_test:da0c8826b1c9df28399772fbbbc00def6e24266ea4769395b086fb5212f858b4', 'no_robots_test:f17e86e400862b58a8f76248b6a0516ef3258bdbcc14e2bf04973c276cb80adf', 'no_robots_test:e8e0ae19872ede1c9e4f75e62a31cbd2008befe91b60b1efceec9d82a68068ee', 'no_robots_test:a8bf210a9bbec3800386a7c5c31d74e89eb4331209ff9707c6ab6af269ffcf11', 'no_robots_test:69d2b75a5774cf0cc7f61356d15f46ce5f7e847a6ae2fd7d80b844729ee66533', 'no_robots_test:f390cc2e8411ec903c73f3f4f63d319ff38697806fc2e2cc3a919ee9f4de7df9', 'no_robots_test:91c266537d1b7b14576858b3cffc0e0c64e067f25fc427b1ccd9f57deb3ab510', 'no_robots_test:9bb61f01d987accca140d9b7a08cf663da8c4647707509d0f849e1a6d4618845', 'no_robots_test:1b0d0852a3458d9e67d6aaee4a56ad43a02a5e06e0b7ce12d3f488768bffb453', 'no_robots_test:c35fbe35a264b1d4bb9266ce6d88abb1d932379dd81c1adc52db0f2e41f6777b', 'no_robots_test:601da7a0629ec217772580a3120ac9fc06a6df190ed10780e7da422cf7f9262a', 'no_robots_test:cc3cdef5cb453bcfea86564234a8d2bbd1c5ee3806098531fcaf2014f25705b1', 'no_robots_test:c1b58ea5e251db651f6ed3fc547f082837341e585d518ffe13b38f167216e57f', 'no_robots_test:85b235f4feda83914fdb0cbb3829ceb72a67a0cad5db3385cd00342dd5c5adc7', 'no_robots_test:f52d6383e3acbd487bdb7628e5e1f40615221a18987e99010a5a1ccd9f1d7cb0', 'no_robots_test:e6fd684789090b25ab723bbdd2fffc97cb47f20ddab417d0fc0571f848734469', 'no_robots_test:c4a9dd28310b012602050b7aebce6fc24ac6970da91c0606343724aa054f582a', 'no_robots_test:abd71530ee6e630d3ec7d965c754e672013f3e08785c888ae03a54545ca06aea', 'no_robots_test:6e2bfc6786ee24a14685bb3e2bff4e30c235573cce6a30e6a4f34648872945a3', 'no_robots_test:0bd65e73a8f7bcc45be8767197aa1d949f05a16c544f4979662418a20974fb95', 'no_robots_test:c5844637317399e7d5b233c18d7ac5cdbf35eb0c8828c5c9502a28c4702a7201', 'no_robots_test:51113c20a33637c45ffa7790adf858b82411041fd590a33eb7237a8dcc20f759', 'no_robots_test:ef8990846d162db707da43ce86ff6679aef342edf48271f8c56a6eaea6b757b2', 'no_robots_test:9205274fb686fc486f4bcdebb1db6ff5ba082910ec126fe4e7a45b7c4e326502', 'no_robots_test:12a51577fc8c8f57379974dff63caa82cfee85878af091db7e9ed8bef0c2dff7', 'no_robots_test:1e2f3bba465c89ee6540b3fcbe41b69530214abc3a22c91f3abd3b0268dce6f7', 'no_robots_test:59fd818054494e1765970af339112c6adf8fd23735c5d25d9737f96c3d0d915e', 'no_robots_test:3fd1549f3fbcf76e94f71ab625d154f0de522d1a7d8bd50f010c440921de6a93', 'no_robots_test:44ad24bcbe033d894271593fe623ca666021144e28ba110d46cd84435dba393d', 'no_robots_test:96e2f8ebd4953035715526d9a61b0d821619b54e49dca59e0a27ac38660c1f30', 'no_robots_test:e899cf5f0a16dfb8a99c24079edd1daf67e29471990a5dee209266b674594163', 'no_robots_test:da0b52f4093106f56b7404adbb8159a61bcc8cb7941f53c70323e5d874e8875e', 'no_robots_test:a2a9a52bff5d204d803b507d62782260485e0f99e39b462c864a9ced696daadb', 'no_robots_test:b4626c5a09a0e78cd163ede5e329c94dcf7af010b4cb657b5e90e35fccd548cd', 'no_robots_test:a711c95c8b8132371034deda9d96ebf86b4e3c7a6ad82fe08569725c74274079', 'no_robots_test:8380a993af2c8f279ac14e503846912dfbcde296077027b9f33743ae3c8e77e2', 'no_robots_test:ae7bbb65b9624d622a74937935bd701d475c1a178fe315de73b92e47ee9fd5f1', 'no_robots_test:fafd92407ddf89c0194177a60f58a38a1407d1c0dfa055df0367a7853ed134b9', 'no_robots_test:92dcd250215c49ee91f3bedffd13233cebc6883c582c00f9e5daa52ac0dd92b7', 'no_robots_test:04f4e8dcb7a85d3d2942a5b8a88dba98e688b47fb767d15e5d6a6580cf920dd1', 'no_robots_test:98256cd92ae4fa5dce574e0389c873fca0c1accc50ddb955b6a0159bca065620', 'no_robots_test:140c8928abacd14de28e471f9b72ba39b1fd28d49f2901fe084745f4d2278ee5', 'no_robots_test:2109bf5c5db973ca8ff4b138a9796e29e20be366383d585af45a84e05038ea39', 'no_robots_test:5f66fef6384c7a95e3778c9c5f46cadd6318ce1888d9e2044c9e38a59192dcca', 'no_robots_test:50402f52bfb645ff79958783d68aa9790de3615cb436dfe3ed8d46164a80bfd8', 'no_robots_test:cdeb6dcc295cafe0ed298573af3444ac8fe409ca6032f0f5a1c52cae717e3187', 'no_robots_test:1b2930d8d0408970b01f3d4522f10d8c1fe03a47ab6366f1d2370293ab74b326', 'no_robots_test:1bf1accc704426d12687e1ba37ca0bece147d542dbef4e9ed0d5c3abc9fadc03', 'no_robots_test:0b9b9d2cfbc490f3f45f1bf113df46f68e78ffe0689fe761740adb1e53f8b20c', 'no_robots_test:76532c9fd99ea816721df2cef8b59592f80eb658ee02f3392aefc00f34da245a', 'no_robots_test:5b77f923577ba1dd1c4a709eaf66597c54d52e7810be27543838e2f1314206f6', 'no_robots_test:9f2696fa31f6f52d177f0acde38b92505c990b9a2cb440af41bababe680ca217', 'no_robots_test:21d5e6f61e5d2258f80580d708ec4285fc824e07c92582b63b35988f019091e2', 'no_robots_test:e0d5085e39c268c69847de78014edf194ea0fc5c2868c14fe5059390b7cb9940', 'no_robots_test:bdfed4ee300d6bff796ae268f6f83bfaae10e71aa8ede3dde72554e7eaf79b55', 'no_robots_test:7d5dc53024c3085f99c8102e249b7da704ba08b65f33f99bed3327ca3726f72f', 'no_robots_test:63d767b55aa04b962cab270eee9e64b65aaf34af3aa9781167c228dd0e82f67c', 'no_robots_test:9329174e2ac800db587384bd62c32bf99604ad657176f524f83263251d20bca5', 'no_robots_test:7c4214e958ae2abd2be5d8b652d5915b494776dc94af3873d2d6c3344e851f62', 'no_robots_test:0dc3429898c88946ff7e6b1d33b8ba1ca2fe61216f700a9d88df16e14a6b7d8d', 'no_robots_test:5991d65bc74447559f555e0a808f886fb6645f3529656ddd63b8d087f2df7f27', 'no_robots_test:9beb41a989ac57f4fdc979d80b3b65eb99d25b97c9f664eb42bcaa16ccd74267', 'no_robots_test:aadb45cc8d2e48853f3e7d8f759532646d013559d46b7fc72c60042d3f154064', 'no_robots_test:4f5195b9648dfb0a57f64f53e6afc60e78c7b65a7620943ffd98947c9170d628', 'no_robots_test:8135293cb7bb33562aac0e08f4942f44ad7d7858ddbbcdda57ca83f234588846', 'no_robots_test:d1e66a5ced13c36d30989f5776239534594765d1bf8cf40144eed2e913e24d52', 'no_robots_test:a2cc15697d3bad72aa51063c3d8d42753ee59d965111cf28aecc97dded3d8376', 'no_robots_test:3410cd90f220004a96c7f8bfa1396589594d36100f6b48c632238fd97c25f051', 'no_robots_test:0512bb67304464c586c502af3dfc689a18a64da1493ac248b30782ceb219e103', 'no_robots_test:4b535a929ec12ec2fa17ee650e3339a558e495254049d037bd55d881614b7993', 'no_robots_test:dc1c6bf4a49f7ad4a1b65a21092307059639a4d54c70943c81f70ef5595acd00', 'no_robots_test:f02e1582f19aceb3804c56a778dbe12f55fe8a8904e555c8b8f5854b2d2e2490', 'no_robots_test:a45ba472e28e8ea090c83ab4d9d909c24591f06bfe9d7fa29b08eefc40fb486e', 'no_robots_test:cb0115b30980ef2c67f726ee3b246b1a9a48c862cc96e9d5d7f932465113df15', 'no_robots_test:21d96307542784354781725acfac689570738bbd4701d34d7fef620028a65ab3', 'no_robots_test:cf187936417f4e620db64edacc001a21ea66cad7ce1632b3b695834e59937c36', 'no_robots_test:ea03a22f943868af40ddde4838466261bc866a90f93ba57dc9762af5dd1d1f02', 'no_robots_test:b1d03bc76343f1fed66b69110f521554c64cf85be99e8465fb9d683e712dbf2e', 'no_robots_test:89b59d3fd692af01d07cffca31fa8206144455daef39e21834fa33fa717eccbd', 'no_robots_test:3f57eb796307f7079b4b17d5ad1b373027a3d8d6effafe8195d7f07c0c3adc7d', 'no_robots_test:5379c8e23f96ecbe07278583d4a1bf0cae261c8859f5eaf2fe71cd48dd372b19', 'no_robots_test:5d57c71c8eb4151b7882399a736fa1f76cee5b963bd81df6c71449843d6a3a78', 'no_robots_test:c1e734b7c9273ade357686249bef609292f02928f4d7e92aaf8e804903705dcf', 'no_robots_test:acaf6bbf25fd178fbcec73c0c442c059764b5fb6574737f115be96448f0a949e', 'no_robots_test:2bf1aaceb022d29d07b3592686801bc38669d7cc3b53a39a493b9fcbe341cba7', 'no_robots_test:def95674a89f7c0af7e5effafea662aea97fab147eceb9c26522faf022f9c5fe', 'no_robots_test:9aa4a72006d99dbfa3577a09727a94f45fe46287f36c6a57f05277c5ee7241ab', 'no_robots_test:1f3fc92dfd7a802a4522cb83047fce264d858342bdd1ba74a6f1ec4b70670436', 'no_robots_test:f027a06e3a6d9f8e7884505e882765afab994a7af76a45a17ff1ee2019b87935', 'no_robots_test:58ff17be13248eac49ee8819e0c0932a24aa86ce83bae6c5a81606790fba7b35', 'no_robots_test:d181278e1b38176c0969f3353fff5e6c420e04b575910d912fc520e607435836', 'no_robots_test:18c97df1c8de043206f91f144ab63cbaaff8daf413e985c89e707dd3fec96e01', 'no_robots_test:a8d7070f3b2eadd68ee04484aeee162965cfa87c8944030ddb201caa81afe852', 'no_robots_test:57518a6bceea3fd9ffa74011999efd87493f1c5db060a4aa769b9be7848af626', 'no_robots_test:87914ff0fe55338940f93023f9753fe82086fa3f6e8a9eda1a777acc015cf0ac', 'no_robots_test:7559d264f51a24cb19d4f5975adfd3311da418ff021a7b34b425ae468c2f3a03', 'no_robots_test:ac1507a57ad89bb7bc2bbc1c369c9b85a9e6eabd82d2fdb646a555dca07e8a8f', 'no_robots_test:5cdc678ca7768ca7b56af0acd0bd8beed33e962c09fae12c4593ad3fb4e7b686', 'no_robots_test:10d1712f547e45c910c0ace8c5df343bcfe60cb9674565c75f44c37c9ef27b4a', 'no_robots_test:f23f7cbd01c6c31d2cf42ab2a77ccd8990c2df24aae4f7fea9333c169b1ebef5', 'no_robots_test:62ad8ad2fb5e912a6a726ce97148ab183e00836f1f419cb36b40ce9b539f966b', 'no_robots_test:f1c772697dfaaeac06b48f38adb234478015161fa3ff747863ab1a4fa52546c5', 'no_robots_test:ac0d55915dbc688034a5fa10e0a0567a2e43baafed48b670e27a99a753d23c5d', 'no_robots_test:12aab43789e2f7d3146b3176b50852a78331f6ab86ec81f83cc16f5f33ea9ccc', 'no_robots_test:a47718eb12402f37e9fd94c2155173f37ff201f6e1023e1bec5fde1465a84024', 'no_robots_test:4ad5e260eba22fdeba20d6e656bdfbc9b3594bee49a1bb22a595b51cd96992af', 'no_robots_test:879a1ad0ecb760e10299434681ba0e095059acf521f96b016b7a3cde37bdb2b0', 'no_robots_test:8bb586e839cef9a28ef6fa93a819eaf4c00c71772ab77b6dd895ad053536a777', 'no_robots_test:df61fa815e8c0741d159d29c8942deabfeb19d84d7ebe78a5aa6ab18f9f0c1bb', 'no_robots_test:7b9040b1d3b6856c5515e7c3d8d835e9d842b146723068447b4f4ba797e89c32', 'no_robots_test:eed1bf7ddb070685755afefb800d9b3501a4d37c0dfb2dcff9b466f13e9a51b1', 'no_robots_test:c2c3159fafc7d47e194430e37ebe9e1b7f624fca4b0f713e8796b14482fbd1e6', 'no_robots_test:bd00fc3125a0b2024594521b7e88e01056379c60de1104cd3cd30b1d6b86018e', 'no_robots_test:bdf651db6af463bac2baaa81cd5531391ee680381ab3ec527827f266704f87be', 'no_robots_test:7a18aac879b7e987f2ac1e13262a9938bdcf98a10e9882b15432cb71c04b0e8c', 'no_robots_test:6353dab1d3388095c5fa4bdfe6cb081ed487aa771b0295c592712ff348594cb1', 'no_robots_test:bc3916b72a42f1e5762f0b6ec42187c26c4be4e1bdfc91ee538d2ca24a88e4d1', 'no_robots_test:ad428e8ceee2a71a99099898cdc3502664f5ceff3546b24068980c1002fe61d1', 'no_robots_test:73421e0bdb4bfeb54712175074ae883bda34be646e072d60c9ff7680629b1e72', 'no_robots_test:99c31abd504316002052b5a4599e5ca23850b258e7712e71910e06f9a8f8ddca', 'no_robots_test:edcbfaa28a53505efeb660324de996f5f87064f05f82c00a430b4bf693563e24', 'no_robots_test:4d5a125c091b1330ad20f9c6266cef55a59d453c7faadc3f75b7f310d118f580', 'no_robots_test:711dbf4713654879d2ed546e27e1758c4c41508cadf57b17f7098ec8d9cb4d32', 'no_robots_test:1d206f2103e90eac0254aa1d3274e9b01645c4a4ba106d87dfe15c1f1e034965', 'no_robots_test:27af0d850d8bd239b4d44d381f524807db5aad1e39b1a652b58fbfc63a766892', 'no_robots_test:a2acba4442cc04a98acb1e4ec53cd5677d85e55f0e539f3346597bf85f07d694', 'no_robots_test:2d91dcc129303876668ca3ebd2082ad0fb4ce76ae99951d801f94e95a7a60404', 'no_robots_test:2065b3c57f02d3e7fb4e531ee740a7abd4715d4c4bf462f910f7d07f8ed49c7b', 'no_robots_test:163bae12e8c1649f03d00c75f1f14392d3a165a705e130e2c8c2ef8072900298', 'no_robots_test:627f3274d200d6ebff294410bddd5bdd289e739ab0eec10e2f12b86e9ba1d2c2', 'no_robots_test:6da2d4509f61ee54c1e1517dbd90130732b33323b86eb203bd802506eef0f6f5', 'no_robots_test:f0bfe3f8637787f7feade76b0b4542f98eaa7a6979db99717babbe6d773e2dc8', 'no_robots_test:aa7f0e5cdfb6901d2d90d3e7208e66ef152eb4c375d6ca49f11c8595426fb5fa', 'no_robots_test:359c18b053c7ee99c28aaef1489af3e7fdec5696b9c396819469c0fae0abac37', 'no_robots_test:292ac83dea709c12c9fac33c85cd40881cc9bcf5ed4afdbfd63debfd61077bf6', 'no_robots_test:0613f4755ddc2493e8e837f455e836df25da9bfa3ff7af7b3730a27b6f5e6b45', 'no_robots_test:49432f201791c5d2f041d3a9f15fbe8f040e2ee6c3538e3681828d966db63c97', 'no_robots_test:a3bb1debb936705b1ef7521ef1e9c15e800b67be60014884374f9b5036de27c0', 'no_robots_test:e20eeb892f54c4810c7d93f54778f1d76df20c699cc7bc3df0c25e283a595a83', 'no_robots_test:489ec38b91c95df5035c1d889c2a32ed40ca97fa306732d72589217906a120a2', 'no_robots_test:d1510c80a8ab1d3336f8a94e68efeda4ac4e0c72357b810ff368b0625a7278dd', 'no_robots_test:376025d76297c587ce811b6f6d21599fbb25cf1af8dc4ed92e18aecbbcc40fe3', 'no_robots_test:ebca3e652be5cfb23f84fa73480f2f853fd04daa2fdb50575ead2a53b146d443', 'no_robots_test:38aa0c7bb0970bf91add7d33abdfe187e34a094b55fc66d2a4536c3edccc5a23', 'no_robots_test:3c75021b544b5c17b1bc159a46bf68c84f3c3f6985a3a45e0534c42dede8ed30', 'no_robots_test:a74836ebd3c90c383a4008391560ec957dfa0b5da9e29f37cbcb25aa03162300', 'no_robots_test:ed7b90363e2b3e866e549e4cad67bfbe47b984f6d424dfc5c6ef43bcbc744545', 'no_robots_test:59b4cee67aabb257050e24350386b215c61af9a4e00bf1b6044bedd14ab864f8', 'no_robots_test:7bc58574708b8a53410195e1d914dc5a86428b8cc02a383a0f47ddb0c211064c', 'no_robots_test:17b62a7ecf91cae6ab14f5504d18da30b44396a30219e2b824a59607e58053a5', 'no_robots_test:832d80a522ed3d18ad84965c457e919336a091b5b525f105cedc909a1a6b42c7', 'no_robots_test:1ab776c45860a736c7a65b2070dc7d57a58f64ecccffd8c5e0b5220163d129b2', 'no_robots_test:0dde5c58440c2832f06ee8b7bdbb39e7eb7e703d3722d3903e37972b98f758d6', 'no_robots_test:dbbe795ab6edb4b0b00d7dc488041c666a0050c0630291a71ac00a77311013e9', 'no_robots_test:0b8225dc73fa4c390080ebee2a1f6c1aefda82980c02ade6aabe003b2a607778', 'no_robots_test:4402a30e69c901a660fb7000be2a91ae4fb85d240762156b252fbbaebfcb35c4', 'no_robots_test:190800e5fe6ec8102868c2a20fe72c3bcce3d47b09e9ce6f89378df9d69d8a55', 'no_robots_test:2933db9a81070f5a3a907dddc7bfb53954204e9ce6accdbe16fa8236e73702bd', 'no_robots_test:9b99f22ca3ad129385462592c43ee852b5bc1b143116c69f4a498cc2716b2f37', 'no_robots_test:f15bf5f600fde612c62aac19aacc96fec9d5492ea20cd882fcf438f7da528fdc', 'no_robots_test:3c75dd3b9c443c578595c6e6254bab4a402af66ae303c3adcd7d7b0d12fe356f', 'no_robots_test:6977eba7eabf93213bdb09bbd79c76d48d40f5495b61e60cac9d7251107dd65e', 'no_robots_test:2e174209ec79d2c77551ad995f0793a105c2a276aba6e540a734b46c376b95ac', 'no_robots_test:dc9914ebb51f869a655d2c711c3026c5a946e7f5a5f0c4207e5e59996f28fc3a', 'no_robots_test:6c6e51c01ed43bf768cd647ee633051ba964018ba50398b94778a6336d79cc7d', 'no_robots_test:8e459a433eee96c1489749574fdb1251cf6160e0867970d21b57f8a0c07bcd5b', 'no_robots_test:396b9869a1bcf5dc03b28b5b7d9beca4bcba0e336601de2c72d753a5581c0e7e', 'no_robots_test:ba3186534d194b706f2fafd73ffeba8eaf369eb1b8bc7cd5735f6b832eb63345', 'no_robots_test:8ca28b279177640a66bba4418407eaac428b4b9929be2621053e528c4787d678', 'no_robots_test:0d085a2a920a21efe14671cf9783a18cedbf443a371982632b2daf77b745e63c', 'no_robots_test:0aff4c8b522ebeeb637127bcc660272fc3be476548731845e0a98d0d7252c6a8', 'no_robots_test:034aeca97edb0026c8f6b28015f96f80e64ed2185e47ca5953bb3558544bf677', 'no_robots_test:8e748b973a0f9ca774a7fafc2cfb916b4b3fff17f2aa52dbdc4efd99a78a0f42', 'no_robots_test:9620fd7c9182bde749653ef79cfadcfbb0114013d649300cb1137c70fbbbf2aa', 'no_robots_test:7e5c5cd4c0281d3379244965dc6614199c6da3e959135a65dc64b8fe9bfbe3c6', 'no_robots_test:e8d7adc6514830d95bd6d2eefdab4c5f4ab86135aa4f6fb94c57f45965d8bf44', 'no_robots_test:04a42213adc94ff11ab0c8f2b9d3c1b6a09ab88a018ff2674ac46cc776245585', 'no_robots_test:43e34875cd8505e545ce6578bacc3f0a0731d1871f829dedb3ebcfedbc125ab3', 'no_robots_test:079e49e7313d18925ddc6d79ee2bfdaa6efe110fd5e5154d68eb30a3aeb303ce', 'no_robots_test:b1538637e504a357ff8f6187d26c774dabf66c820133e7386de0ef4b9939a9ff', 'no_robots_test:9637d09548e7cfb3a2254681d76b906f6736834dc7bb56bc30d30e3ef122ff92', 'no_robots_test:4e780fcb9b95852d4003a3125728cd59ac9eaa361574de7b424e834429b2f94b', 'no_robots_test:ebe773c8ce5b980e8534de968460abea42946f338700cab3952e745f1edf34c1', 'no_robots_test:f40b5870f2b4637108f9e0e624e635b87b8a481c570e561213cfb83997c71fcf', 'no_robots_test:a457eaad92c901bfa6b421dbca85a0187a55a0c1d3db5c3190118b0f9762840e', 'no_robots_test:4a35736bd4adcf4f2738d714126f7e1ee631b270854f5f9caf763ee6b0b914ed', 'no_robots_test:ff458369e71a6c78f6c963ef11c04a41df465ef908baa09bc39c2fd608ebb047', 'no_robots_test:6d04c2f474c12831ca516bc6b570f14380577896c9430fc0f50c5189b50a61c7', 'no_robots_test:4fda661d52da94ab5575570229f0fcfbc5d07d86da03f3c689a44bbc7e9183ff', 'no_robots_test:7d1a1e1b267ad0722a86ca4fad6ddbebd51176842040b291e0008de019ce5379', 'no_robots_test:24e9ac536dfc2c36b548475cbfdc400ae21c9b5566d6152a3d126f52b43fee25', 'no_robots_test:02f3e506860f9c0a76c25e040d4ab0104d61bf6759c0aa85ad31ee64bf721eb1', 'no_robots_test:c79fdcbd3dfb18027a63eded6f242968c518642e7862334f825cadbe2007f1d1', 'no_robots_test:0e414e0a370e42b00e9e292c176ab1216c7a51b8347c465e2be9d8e10f44af3b', 'no_robots_test:e9c46210587c0ce455a20422f65d5471275eb38dc4b6db98fd2144bcff13ae72', 'no_robots_test:3f7aa67c5e926f3901db8fbaf16761392bd403ef426125b223631ec3b2517ac8', 'no_robots_test:a6deacccb8af5a3a0ea0346c92c9370bdd52ac9227fe360ac5596c76d1bbbd8c', 'no_robots_test:e825b5cbbaba4c14f72a0856896dd5b523a871ab2b9f2dcd15d776a2b4aabfa4', 'no_robots_test:2bbd6906c056a90062a8ae36294c8d919482503c574113afdc86f13f14fd837b', 'no_robots_test:072f282c80b080141098970c3b463d29c5aae2f69ddd2dac7455badcfc5a89c3', 'no_robots_test:244ecb6b0826574c23d978c03ca05300669ceecf65734363fe097610a6ca25bc', 'no_robots_test:e507dd4c9d1df15f476426251e5a1d650a207b6a5584f7bd4744f0903093600e', 'no_robots_test:2b3cdffb047fc350416d9b20e25c4e70590df1c3c868ffdd44fa545ce0d67610', 'no_robots_test:4c949fbda37ddfda58554ff73a2e224deed8df66695c36a40f8a2d4a134cb9e3', 'no_robots_test:6d6dfc83c69f55a856b1e0b758eaddf68b5543e14cb2ae617743a0d4881824e8', 'no_robots_test:9cc02849ca26fe5b9121d46077bb34eff04fb3e2ea2f82305367c9154d1237b7', 'no_robots_test:2153e9b17536a047acf8a0614c91ab45c9450839e4b2c7660ab25251c173e1c3', 'no_robots_test:8dc045dcc46374809265fe389a46803a26afafe333fa77dc70a1f8c3acdc3963', 'no_robots_test:288e444047682b25ddb5ff63898e6a0d48cb1de3c6c06a65261f8bdb60931468', 'no_robots_test:1905bb8ba7ffff2cff8875d6ddb7a2d85c4fd48873bcfef5c4f71670fa118b68', 'no_robots_test:042108b7bf148d0831e5665ce92715f156541ee00c56b0adbd330b4cd63dcd99', 'no_robots_test:3715688d26cc3544beca7d717c5c663cf2a05625d9ae13d1fdb39cf508f77446', 'no_robots_test:dab34dff6549458647c89e02da31b00b2339599ede1deb6799587b4bd0209106', 'no_robots_test:ee1bf2cb4729ec1e998907fd521b642b8fa17f54dcd3c4ecfd61994b3935b289', 'no_robots_test:e3d7cc21f696e9727960b47df92da81cd681c36ee389272b24cb82839f66d9b8', 'no_robots_test:79cedc57b4ca1fb97ea15691a996378a147499a6e1de0b0e50d9c4c7caf96ea2', 'no_robots_test:d95f75bba38b5fb8923367b6c8149cae81ba5d31e76f960e55db774d641f3ae9', 'no_robots_test:1f1c25dd4f795b151f180ab18467385fd533988876fb5303fb5bb3459e35c23a', 'no_robots_test:09d47615e1590057bac2dc5ce27d3ff90f20db6b531672e5ad57699382a0da08', 'no_robots_test:a6416ec59f8e7fe9867476cbb4f5f44bfdd6e962fce1bb00814a141cb3780234', 'no_robots_test:e2caa2ddf7d8e2f8b2c23d288d2b6efc376a4e823ffe09a8af191a44659a4b7b', 'no_robots_test:a1f930ab77dda26f05c58851efc4c27dbc6e180ec529c04a8ed40e43cd8d0304', 'no_robots_test:c721adad90dcd07ebbf863bbbd0c4912f833fab99ac96db9f1d5f833c51eb896', 'no_robots_test:9aec927595bd10316b1df8dcc0df499655280e584a0576047e056f1cb4366d9c', 'no_robots_test:3efd76547ebd59f65357d2040a3b63b92ada7655b9d2c4de25872503038cb13e', 'no_robots_test:3cf7583809cc9110e00c65652f69c9235ecb294741c261595eb4ef71d9fd537c', 'no_robots_test:1b8ef3dce83ad90f2c1a18eb70b97ec2cbc3c25663448c05014503d1a4fd3ed5', 'no_robots_test:c4eace49f52ea1066fe19654a8d625211ec377ad9901c86888dc5ad4be6fdcee', 'no_robots_test:0907eb27ebbf46386b02ca9314935c115cdbdd8382c6370817438e4fc2097819', 'no_robots_test:fb551f033bfede2b3cd283a2628bb5c46f4dfb47a97e6f477b5288d358ad4b72', 'no_robots_test:95b5066b66039db0dbb8ab6788922e68fde8517e20552c6cda3fc0e3499d316a', 'no_robots_test:c27801ad6b5ebadf46dd97da83476952a72b99495ebc85677516437e49c09fbf', 'no_robots_test:e31053f7b489a3ba30b1011663175d1a13fc350b94840af286aea356c829599e', 'no_robots_test:a88b3d44f1598abfb32011ef71e859618a69c60e54d77ac0477a29d649036625', 'no_robots_test:a210dfc781291b83f2b82a299e82c61d90617500e34395c42a53220b22fb32b0', 'no_robots_test:756d31fa74b296203c9450a5ded21a07492f0f99caf7c982abf61a93a9c3ec56', 'no_robots_test:470dce010416538f33aaeb18822ccbdf5f5e1da5749326a11100cab5b54f44db', 'no_robots_test:d9f074817f0647ebb6d9d6a879598fc4394ae7c63b56cc55a147a2b8ef27aa27', 'no_robots_test:fdcc2616f33ae53e0f3121b5cf7cc998b31a8657f3581552a2646c28702f302b', 'no_robots_test:9a9300da4935003f03f16f85b9697b58b533353f121a8be641e1c46aaea3d6f3', 'no_robots_test:93f3c8cc7dece34fdca51a61199b09bd96d8a2d0d5526bae764c07a97602a921', 'no_robots_test:0b93de1a6ea093a5807b24dd5c14f32a952d548e14cdbc92d20d5cbc831546b8', 'no_robots_test:36674ceea31c0eefa67d12528bf92ddd91263cfb12fbe08bcd2631a52dd61188', 'no_robots_test:e266e32ac7319880ff40641c9ea49f61154ce74ce396876cc973d70708946f7d', 'no_robots_test:a1521cb0aa1aa83ec0dc5e3a52234a27e14576e75751b4704480ebd16ac6e396', 'no_robots_test:a794f05f5d6687b8a2e78d904a89209812a47276ad51ed1405043d45b1500cab', 'no_robots_test:27d5c23de1b1d5746a570fcb287b947bf3abec3a5a2948cb081f8daf5c285b6b', 'no_robots_test:9f63c208fe95b14e13899e0207f0d42a9a816b8674a3892c3c8de74b07b70c7d', 'no_robots_test:04795cf6ec37a7dd935c1de66d84d8ac0d764cdf12fac297d129f48dcfaa8d79', 'no_robots_test:afd6af67cc1816d99f86b3e059ab2e77aea944c07b1838c27e6eef57a1400985', 'no_robots_test:cbec88e3309b7648c023d9e2114e2d7595cc9aa18067c25391252004042c8eb9', 'no_robots_test:5a0a73e9962d364ed3eeb4d132f2499e7047e2272808600a290a2fdab270f074', 'no_robots_test:f74746e22e3b69428e9f6bc6ea0561480c8f0ed4bd977656197db9521368fee8', 'no_robots_test:e0b1ce063570abea18f6ed8dbeadb06d796c243f7e6a2a1f49379e74384d5ba6', 'no_robots_test:66b6335c0c576b405ed1668e632edbedd0eb09146dd4e4d84aca2b6043511aea', 'no_robots_test:079c5a5713af4f78a53df64e7b0464359e30f5fedcfa1fee25cc46b177c44367', 'no_robots_test:d436fce6076f3110e1b20da47f43d8fd0e643a43d36af478ed325f1061eddc79', 'no_robots_test:da13290dda7f6ac430bdd317de487a6f9fa79e1b0ce8b353f948980a519cf952', 'no_robots_test:f044562dab2d66d59ffa187a93db0a4d4eef2217a7c143f944312254e82913cc', 'no_robots_test:940e3ea02beb3b61613794d1b427bf37f30078633244e2a2d3a3a17a169d2350', 'no_robots_test:749dd218364d72a3c4022bc6665491204d016ba8717793b88665219a4b4d9c70', 'no_robots_test:e10eb2e3fd3cbcbc45858578621b9b4e64aca3dd8f3b0ad39a472fa3c490f660', 'no_robots_test:36e1d930e74392cca2528fe06bd8f0d38befdde3c3781b8922041dd688d55235', 'no_robots_test:ecdb34794b24ea6e65ac66a1700160f4864589bb77a5def4591fe996701cb06e', 'no_robots_test:47e591d09b7363112580b3eefe8ed4da5f274dccd3619a2704027db79f941198', 'no_robots_test:f68dd2578ad9dfebdec7bcd8caae2e5d4459159dcfbce130fb6ee6902c18b836', 'no_robots_test:c2abe99df0a43a558ebb63151afd3f8a96f884b33495437b5917b0d6099fd599', 'no_robots_test:3ab7f8ff8f4372b640737a33505112b854b4d6bc35d9e87a4cf73ca9dbbe2f14', 'no_robots_test:1045319c37d98f4f7462681fc50423762cafeb00bd2925484b3d429718e8ff8c', 'no_robots_test:9d3f9dc6ca94a0bdba137665cb1d8d9e4b76d78fdd9a79e7e4ac963bda7e0f38', 'no_robots_test:d8e91a51b7e31c9367cb2bfc5f4418870271355df0d3048599ed2f1d61bac77f', 'no_robots_test:5a911dae756fdfd96b80d4406b261fe658cf900bf6ea2281c59b2e87df796a24', 'no_robots_test:070995ef4c7e899b073a6b1e03a1c0a91d8f6e2917b867ebf75bce02027b2653', 'no_robots_test:51e7e7e69771e152110bd3673461509ee7e0c513dcf590703f6d587bb65ed706', 'no_robots_test:4377ce8bd0f44aa7114983c2d48b23862106b0f247b9199a0ab9926f50dfd80b', 'no_robots_test:4969e6d2e7da9be81ccbbdb18b575ba0b363066b5365ca134b59285bf5c6afd3', 'no_robots_test:2f4b66e0168b2cf7e7c260d3f3b7a18df48f4984fdae0a895561c6a01fd77c88', 'no_robots_test:dc306933ec2a6f7ee590c6de309bbdad91d0f668aca834db27cdc4ecfb5ac7d8', 'no_robots_test:3232792c0b1f58bb36128a00bbe8a2abdf24fddac8c92ba386018ebe34756dae', 'no_robots_test:5ee45f9ebff4e75410b1128889f9d0ca7556b223e69df33334075761d1c7a57e', 'no_robots_test:f6c76517ce8ed01ce548ea7c86ffc53a5fe7afe7984a166755b5e35eeb99099c', 'no_robots_test:57a499002a099639b52fb3dfdf516feb745c14457182340aebbb3546de7eec77', 'no_robots_test:1c5db2224424da86a908bfc9f21425d8669300e88205241d97d0c7a9b4324a6a', 'no_robots_test:2ace06c7fd726671319de8192f3fe5480f5297faab8f09753c1cfe7d6df294fd', 'no_robots_test:a3b22afe88af8a1377646606f9f4df393ac0bc931a643220a32095285895de97', 'no_robots_test:86c835efe40d8ef93ca1608e77a2268143da853d0f60a714e1284fe606e6b4df', 'no_robots_test:0e43302941845c64fb7ba5fca1ef39612a906c9fc81c3fb7753ff7ba3b30687d', 'no_robots_test:d63dd41a84b46571478cb5a4903d5efce1b77515b3e3e5acee602f4a56d0783a', 'no_robots_test:07727af96427cfb80e78aba4d505f97dde11e3c5969f44fe5664b45e8b4e7df7', 'no_robots_test:d0aede9a69080a3131f709faa0ec3d99aecd603e981414ee70d2df4d39bea02d', 'no_robots_test:0ca28e9e453502956ead1128cec5019004c58e33cba5929f5301f3763428216c', 'no_robots_test:764691c4fe0c71bcacf5e05c3b4a120547e80d8c365e6edeefa6a40298f04faa', 'no_robots_test:c221a1f994cff9c2f34b9aa9e41a55163172ddae96767c1d20c1965b48080017', 'no_robots_test:4ac2c6de8b0e256bde22bd47ede3e8ce6b1c3df1b1e2dd0e3eb286e2bb325bef', 'no_robots_test:6a07c07c04281930a7048bda680a6241c65710437584d777401158b0c57554c8', 'no_robots_test:c6c5baccf1fd2a97d0043db12d7d33d85377a8a924e43eee946b3bc18ed8ebb1', 'no_robots_test:50afd036b32ea68be44204ffab02e3f5cb85068de3d905b820844c09b77e17a5', 'no_robots_test:7d8b08737912472872ed2932afe7af99bc72e16457a76b9f91f6b6e376284f24', 'no_robots_test:585e892fa64acb013514af77c36f63c776983e5cfef4563790464fc6cfdfbfde', 'no_robots_test:690738484383e06723019f31ae210f7306246191c01c3d5a09c4f665b7624f1f', 'no_robots_test:4464c320e01db719e51909b974243edc0e7b45f08cc6b30d4d31ac6f13f2e67c', 'no_robots_test:700bc710519bc0de70046303a32891ac5542679ef6ca1030f3bbc8bfefdc2a17', 'no_robots_test:8b6453aa02539744c0b316eb03e2d64aa90369280a65da600f6c391472b94963', 'no_robots_test:3e0a50a9d76572aed087981deeb71f851ea0e9ce59ef7a79dd5b14ac82c38c84', 'no_robots_test:6367ce45caa5d0f0b1acb41b2f53e424f993478d1466f4448a4a97dc495a7222', 'no_robots_test:e473b2438fd9d0a06a40ad46f9a3ffeccd8d0ad4e5749b9d1ccba0eeac5a3025', 'no_robots_test:40995aedb42a2ce8a74fdc801dc7a3c7a4e50206d0820dfaa35b47f5bb76bf9a', 'no_robots_test:c0e4991c7c924b78a5cff690c322f7cdd0e82062b55130fb63c19f2b4da79188', 'no_robots_test:45c8c3c63e02bf5ed5c99b208cdf423a53371f41e59d852c2678ee637aea8ba5', 'no_robots_test:ed6df8fada20e3613a2ee2142eb619726f7389f0b6464480a37e7f675dacf148', 'no_robots_test:76aee18285d18dabcec5cb59f7aa2a0190bbdb0a4f64eb6a4db95976e8d227ca', 'no_robots_test:62829e5b79946e964e3a04465f37d7f8d3d702e2fa342dbf7fbe4441aa05ff23', 'no_robots_test:c14c3c4b63794c8b534c6a60fa3338b1cadc10b24bf8ef69bdb04854b5224333', 'no_robots_test:9ea362fd9c2b04083756e2c03b02b4d5d334826313b7c36eb45f922068ccdb80', 'no_robots_test:446c0186eeb24e8a43d0ab7dd13d314a20e86b3523aa23dc1d8e68422e7b7cce', 'no_robots_test:489c7abb740ed0b9bb6bc704595edf4c94f1f9f4ac797ff1d6f55d8ea956d8e6', 'no_robots_test:002ab8b85a36e6c5464c96594c1046aaad0832b2b7ba59b7c60f8d5bf1839d14', 'no_robots_test:73d6f61d9fc2261b5ff4fc6a130ce46e5f759fdd82536f4458150cc9abe67453', 'no_robots_test:f3f094b2aaa7c46b1dc50d4975a008bd30230089ebefafa9724184be73f84d17', 'no_robots_test:c70281f8e81ec2249e2b6ec296b0d5158860523a83a3d6ece0c11d534f24fc3d', 'no_robots_test:23b988274475e59d97dfeaf717327a13d9e3d4df2e73c30cbbca59c1ea842860', 'no_robots_test:9283abbe02ec6e09f3ce2719b02aa2b1dc2f887425a2d5144f923403fb9b54db', 'no_robots_test:a08e2b36113e5d71feb47d60494b84029dec93aab7e1ad658b433eebff8e0ba3', 'no_robots_test:3f02ff68fb4cacef7ce3877c019b13187ab2739d5dd1a82f850852a67025a9b1', 'no_robots_test:0335e3ebae248cd378edc4479b1f7a885172da22e70da830aeaf9622978feec4', 'no_robots_test:02697bcf2ecb738e9532ddba8b7079aa21d8bb9744456dcde524871c3eb728f8', 'no_robots_test:5b34963157310ae9936fd14ff22daa343a9529b3c193544d754eea0a73e5760e', 'no_robots_test:12fe37ce674a2f79d7f2f36211393d9d9d4b97d1a431be0b27000b64a5bb16cd', 'no_robots_test:0c30072a27e82c8fc2f6009a0d08214fb1552c42b1917aa9acbcfe3d1c5d9e91', 'no_robots_test:0d24b407ea10dd9173e8fbb377609559e820302a1bc8ea15f42b5c0356266a1b', 'no_robots_test:602272a99566bf68a5b48979478bceb0b56f74915925ed8a1b0a558935df3584', 'no_robots_test:ecdac8f179582eb850ec28155ea59279e445c219d7bcccc6753cef24a7199a42', 'no_robots_test:46b880155fdd947f395a3009a313bf8cbfe8e137c37b3a614c49585112e0aa0f', 'no_robots_test:65b835d2335e23cf908b10817be1eb5c1bd5dcd3b80bd3e7a46c72d2cd479e8d', 'no_robots_test:48363ab6108604ad6812a9dbe0f17fc52dc68532d3b3bf4d83bfadcea7b99f9a']}}}, 'scores': [{'arm': 'baseline', 'seed': 0, 'metric': 'no_robots_test_token_mean_nll_at_step_100', 'value': 2.0330861653887684, 'evaluator_id': '830529b5110015d8cccda36ffa0fcf180860e8176a1c44e71da3544beaa48c16', 'predictions_ref': 'predictions-confirm-test.jsonl'}, {'arm': 'treatment', 'seed': 0, 'metric': 'no_robots_test_token_mean_nll_at_step_100', 'value': 2.0325384676338447, 'evaluator_id': '830529b5110015d8cccda36ffa0fcf180860e8176a1c44e71da3544beaa48c16', 'predictions_ref': 'predictions-confirm-test.jsonl'}, {'arm': 'baseline', 'seed': 1, 'metric': 'no_robots_test_token_mean_nll_at_step_100', 'value': 2.0314219380012872, 'evaluator_id': '830529b5110015d8cccda36ffa0fcf180860e8176a1c44e71da3544beaa48c16', 'predictions_ref': 'predictions-confirm-test.jsonl'}, {'arm': 'treatment', 'seed': 1, 'metric': 'no_robots_test_token_mean_nll_at_step_100', 'value': 2.030357345510328, 'evaluator_id': '830529b5110015d8cccda36ffa0fcf180860e8176a1c44e71da3544beaa48c16', 'predictions_ref': 'predictions-confirm-test.jsonl'}, {'arm': 'baseline', 'seed': 2, 'metric': 'no_robots_test_token_mean_nll_at_step_100', 'value': 2.030896831835155, 'evaluator_id': '830529b5110015d8cccda36ffa0fcf180860e8176a1c44e71da3544beaa48c16', 'predictions_ref': 'predictions-confirm-test.jsonl'}, {'arm': 'treatment', 'seed': 2, 'metric': 'no_robots_test_token_mean_nll_at_step_100', 'value': 2.0305850384881765, 'evaluator_id': '830529b5110015d8cccda36ffa0fcf180860e8176a1c44e71da3544beaa48c16', 'predictions_ref': 'predictions-confirm-test.jsonl'}], 'comparisons': [{'metric': 'no_robots_test_token_mean_nll_at_step_100', 'arms': ['baseline', 'treatment']}]}

evaluator_validation

{'status': 'comparable', 'issues': [], 'comparisons': [{'metric': 'no_robots_test_token_mean_nll_at_step_100', 'status': 'comparable', 'arms': ['baseline', 'treatment'], 'evaluator_ids': ['830529b5110015d8cccda36ffa0fcf180860e8176a1c44e71da3544beaa48c16'], 'missing_arms': []}]}

feasibility

{'status': 'unknown', 'problems': ['Re-projection required: lora_rank changed or was not recorded', 'Re-projection required: dataset changed or was not recorded', 'Re-projection required: steps changed or was not recorded', 'Re-projection required: n_examples changed or was not recorded', 'Re-projection required: n_eval changed or was not recorded', 'Representative evaluation timing not recorded', 'Representative training timing not recorded', 'Representative setup timing not recorded', 'Unknown timing phase: setup_fork_deploy', 'Unknown timing phase: setup_pilot', 'Unknown timing phase: training_pilot', 'Unknown timing phase: heldout_eval_pilot', 'Unknown timing phase: setup_selection', 'Unknown timing phase: training_selection', 'Unknown timing phase: heldout_eval_selection', 'Unknown timing phase: setup_confirmation', 'Unknown timing phase: training_confirmation', 'Unknown timing phase: heldout_eval_confirmation'], 'wall_seconds': None, 'gpu_hours': None, 'known_gpu_hours': 1.2508076457182566, 'phases': {'recovery': {'wall_seconds': 4502.907524585724, 'gpu_hours': 1.2508076457182566}}, 'generation_counts': None, 'generation_applicability': {'check': 'generation_audit', 'status': 'not_applicable', 'enforce': False, 'reasons': ['spec.generation_audit opts out and no feature it covers is true'], 'features': {'generated_training_data': False}}, 'record': {'config': {'base_model': 'Qwen/Qwen3.5-2B', 'arms': 12, 'selection_steps': 40, 'confirmation_steps': 100, 'batch_size': 32, 'max_seq_len': 2048, 'n_eval_validation': 500, 'n_eval_test': 500, 'n_ifeval_secondary': 541, 'planned_arm_steps': 840}, 'effective_config': {'base_model': 'Qwen/Qwen3.5-2B', 'arms': 12, 'selection_steps': 40, 'confirmation_steps': 100, 'batch_size': 32, 'max_seq_len': 2048, 'n_eval_validation': 500, 'n_eval_test': 500, 'n_ifeval_secondary': 0, 'planned_arm_steps': 840, 'pilot_arms': 2, 'pilot_steps': 10, 'note': 'IFEval dropped (downsizing step 1); LR grid, selection steps, seeds, test NLL unchanged'}, 'primary_endpoint': 'no_robots_test_token_mean_nll_at_step_100', 'source': 'pilot_log.jsonl (10-step 2-arm pilot, measured before the sweep); select_log.jsonl and confirm_log.jsonl measured', 'measurements': {'setup_fork_deploy': {'seconds': 19.0, 'units': 1, 'planned_units': 1, 'samples': 1, 'gpu_count': 1, 'allocation_source': 'fork_config.py trainer_gpus_per_node=1 (single trainer GPU; inference min replicas 0)'}, 'setup_pilot': {'seconds': 285.4358539581299, 'units': 2, 'planned_units': 2, 'samples': 2, 'gpu_count': 1, 'allocation_source': 'fork_config.py trainer_gpus_per_node=1 (single trainer GPU; inference min replicas 0)'}, 'training_pilot': {'seconds': 122.76167058944702, 'units': 20, 'planned_units': 20, 'samples': 640, 'gpu_count': 1, 'allocation_source': 'fork_config.py trainer_gpus_per_node=1 (single trainer GPU; inference min replicas 0)'}, 'heldout_eval_pilot': {'seconds': 73.11771726608276, 'units': 1000, 'planned_units': 1000, 'samples': 1000, 'gpu_count': 1, 'allocation_source': 'fork_config.py trainer_gpus_per_node=1 (single trainer GPU; inference min replicas 0)'}, 'setup_selection': {'seconds': 82.80450391769409, 'units': 6, 'planned_units': 6, 'samples': 6, 'gpu_count': 1, 'allocation_source': 'fork_config.py trainer_gpus_per_node=1 (single trainer GPU; inference min replicas 0)'}, 'training_selection': {'seconds': 494.3076186180115, 'units': 240, 'planned_units': 240, 'samples': 7680, 'gpu_count': 1, 'allocation_source': 'fork_config.py trainer_gpus_per_node=1 (single trainer GPU; inference min replicas 0)'}, 'heldout_eval_selection': {'seconds': 160.32491517066956, 'units': 3000, 'planned_units': 3000, 'samples': 3000, 'gpu_count': 1, 'allocation_source': 'fork_config.py trainer_gpus_per_node=1 (single trainer GPU; inference min replicas 0)'}, 'setup_confirmation': {'seconds': 274.54359698295593, 'units': 6, 'planned_units': 6, 'samples': 6, 'gpu_count': 1, 'allocation_source': 'fork_config.py trainer_gpus_per_node=1 (single trainer GPU; inference min replicas 0)'}, 'training_confirmation': {'seconds': 742.3969576358795, 'units': 600, 'planned_units': 600, 'samples': 19200, 'gpu_count': 1, 'allocation_source': 'fork_config.py trainer_gpus_per_node=1 (single trainer GPU; inference min replicas 0)'}, 'heldout_eval_confirmation': {'seconds': 159.3210573196411, 'units': 3000, 'planned_units': 3000, 'samples': 3000, 'gpu_count': 1, 'allocation_source': 'fork_config.py trainer_gpus_per_node=1 (single trainer GPU; inference min replicas 0)'}}, 'generation': None, 'recovery': {'seconds': 4502.907524585724, 'gpu_count': 1, 'allocation_source': 'fork_config.py trainer_gpus_per_node=1 (single trainer GPU; inference min replicas 0)'}}, 'recorded_at': 1793809272.6893096}

feasibility_reported_verdict

refuted

feasibility_required

True

generation_audit_validation

{'status': 'not_applicable', 'reasons': ['spec.generation_audit opts out and no feature it covers is true'], 'applicability': {'check': 'generation_audit', 'status': 'not_applicable', 'enforce': False, 'reasons': ['spec.generation_audit opts out and no feature it covers is true'], 'features': {'generated_training_data': False}}}

initialization_provenance

{'version': 1, 'arms': [{'arm': 'sel_adamw_lr5e-05_s0', 'phase': 'select', 'base_checkpoint': 'Qwen/Qwen3.5-2B', 'initialization_checkpoint': 'tinker://3e998640432b43e01b7fb42771192b91/weights/select-init-s0', 'source': 'server_response', 'before_first_update': True, 'restore_count': 0, 'optimizer_checks': [{'after_restore': 0, 'before_next_update': True, 'optimizer': 'adamw', 'model': 'Qwen/Qwen3.5-2B', 'rank': 32}], 'initial_output_sha256': 'd7ba8bf1d6c57c98e0583ccf7b1768634e9973631561c4770d0e69e1e8fee0f7', 'evidence_ref': 'select_log.jsonl', 'adapter_sha256': None, 'adapter_note': 'selection arms all start from saved state select-init-s0; per-arm adapter not downloaded, initial output hash recorded'}, {'arm': 'sel_adamw_lr0.0001_s0', 'phase': 'select', 'base_checkpoint': 'Qwen/Qwen3.5-2B', 'initialization_checkpoint': 'tinker://3e998640432b43e01b7fb42771192b91/weights/select-init-s0', 'source': 'server_response', 'before_first_update': True, 'restore_count': 1, 'optimizer_checks': [{'after_restore': 0, 'before_next_update': True, 'optimizer': 'adamw', 'model': 'Qwen/Qwen3.5-2B', 'rank': 32}, {'after_restore': 1, 'before_next_update': True, 'optimizer': 'adamw', 'model': 'Qwen/Qwen3.5-2B', 'rank': 32}], 'initial_output_sha256': 'd7ba8bf1d6c57c98e0583ccf7b1768634e9973631561c4770d0e69e1e8fee0f7', 'evidence_ref': 'select_log.jsonl', 'adapter_sha256': None, 'adapter_note': 'selection arms all start from saved state select-init-s0; per-arm adapter not downloaded, initial output hash recorded'}, {'arm': 'sel_adamw_lr0.0002_s0', 'phase': 'select', 'base_checkpoint': 'Qwen/Qwen3.5-2B', 'initialization_checkpoint': 'tinker://3e998640432b43e01b7fb42771192b91/weights/select-init-s0', 'source': 'server_response', 'before_first_update': True, 'restore_count': 1, 'optimizer_checks': [{'after_restore': 0, 'before_next_update': True, 'optimizer': 'adamw', 'model': 'Qwen/Qwen3.5-2B', 'rank': 32}, {'after_restore': 1, 'before_next_update': True, 'optimizer': 'adamw', 'model': 'Qwen/Qwen3.5-2B', 'rank': 32}], 'initial_output_sha256': 'd7ba8bf1d6c57c98e0583ccf7b1768634e9973631561c4770d0e69e1e8fee0f7', 'evidence_ref': 'select_log.jsonl', 'adapter_sha256': None, 'adapter_note': 'selection arms all start from saved state select-init-s0; per-arm adapter not downloaded, initial output hash recorded'}, {'arm': 'sel_dimuon_lr0.0003_s0', 'phase': 'select', 'base_checkpoint': 'Qwen/Qwen3.5-2B', 'initialization_checkpoint': 'tinker://3e998640432b43e01b7fb42771192b91/weights/select-init-s0', 'source': 'server_response', 'before_first_update': True, 'restore_count': 1, 'optimizer_checks': [{'after_restore': 0, 'before_next_update': True, 'optimizer': 'dimuon', 'model': 'Qwen/Qwen3.5-2B', 'rank': 32}, {'after_restore': 1, 'before_next_update': True, 'optimizer': 'dimuon', 'model': 'Qwen/Qwen3.5-2B', 'rank': 32}], 'initial_output_sha256': 'd7ba8bf1d6c57c98e0583ccf7b1768634e9973631561c4770d0e69e1e8fee0f7', 'evidence_ref': 'select_log.jsonl', 'adapter_sha256': None, 'adapter_note': 'selection arms all start from saved state select-init-s0; per-arm adapter not downloaded, initial output hash recorded'}, {'arm': 'sel_dimuon_lr0.001_s0', 'phase': 'select', 'base_checkpoint': 'Qwen/Qwen3.5-2B', 'initialization_checkpoint': 'tinker://3e998640432b43e01b7fb42771192b91/weights/select-init-s0', 'source': 'server_response', 'before_first_update': True, 'restore_count': 1, 'optimizer_checks': [{'after_restore': 0, 'before_next_update': True, 'optimizer': 'dimuon', 'model': 'Qwen/Qwen3.5-2B', 'rank': 32}, {'after_restore': 1, 'before_next_update': True, 'optimizer': 'dimuon', 'model': 'Qwen/Qwen3.5-2B', 'rank': 32}], 'initial_output_sha256': 'd7ba8bf1d6c57c98e0583ccf7b1768634e9973631561c4770d0e69e1e8fee0f7', 'evidence_ref': 'select_log.jsonl', 'adapter_sha256': None, 'adapter_note': 'selection arms all start from saved state select-init-s0; per-arm adapter not downloaded, initial output hash recorded'}, {'arm': 'sel_dimuon_lr0.003_s0', 'phase': 'select', 'base_checkpoint': 'Qwen/Qwen3.5-2B', 'initialization_checkpoint': 'tinker://3e998640432b43e01b7fb42771192b91/weights/select-init-s0', 'source': 'server_response', 'before_first_update': True, 'restore_count': 1, 'optimizer_checks': [{'after_restore': 0, 'before_next_update': True, 'optimizer': 'dimuon', 'model': 'Qwen/Qwen3.5-2B', 'rank': 32}, {'after_restore': 1, 'before_next_update': True, 'optimizer': 'dimuon', 'model': 'Qwen/Qwen3.5-2B', 'rank': 32}], 'initial_output_sha256': 'd7ba8bf1d6c57c98e0583ccf7b1768634e9973631561c4770d0e69e1e8fee0f7', 'evidence_ref': 'select_log.jsonl', 'adapter_sha256': None, 'adapter_note': 'selection arms all start from saved state select-init-s0; per-arm adapter not downloaded, initial output hash recorded'}, {'arm': 'baseline_adamw_s0', 'phase': 'confirm', 'base_checkpoint': 'Qwen/Qwen3.5-2B', 'initialization_checkpoint': 'tinker://f11c48d0f72f37d4ff9c6cde3cf5e327/weights/confirm-init-s0', 'source': 'server_response', 'before_first_update': True, 'restore_count': 0, 'optimizer_checks': [{'after_restore': 0, 'before_next_update': True, 'optimizer': 'adamw', 'model': 'Qwen/Qwen3.5-2B', 'rank': 32}], 'initial_output_sha256': '6e2313c4c269801a8b9950b4ebee38fbda850114d334dccc1ea46abd084e51bc', 'evidence_ref': 'restore_check.json', 'step0_checkpoint': 'tinker://f11c48d0f72f37d4ff9c6cde3cf5e327/weights/confirm-baseline_adamw_s0-step0', 'adapter_sha256': '51f089a87ece974104b8005791b54925d905618735136ff61525a9e4d5478e93', 'fp32_param_sha256': 'f276ed16271041f69577844cbda84339e64d1bdc810283d3d415212794783e54', 'server_checkpoint_optimizer': 'adamw'}, {'arm': 'treatment_dimuon_s0', 'phase': 'confirm', 'base_checkpoint': 'Qwen/Qwen3.5-2B', 'initialization_checkpoint': 'tinker://f11c48d0f72f37d4ff9c6cde3cf5e327/weights/confirm-init-s0', 'source': 'server_response', 'before_first_update': True, 'restore_count': 1, 'optimizer_checks': [{'after_restore': 0, 'before_next_update': True, 'optimizer': 'dimuon', 'model': 'Qwen/Qwen3.5-2B', 'rank': 32}, {'after_restore': 1, 'before_next_update': True, 'optimizer': 'dimuon', 'model': 'Qwen/Qwen3.5-2B', 'rank': 32}], 'initial_output_sha256': '6e2313c4c269801a8b9950b4ebee38fbda850114d334dccc1ea46abd084e51bc', 'evidence_ref': 'restore_check.json', 'step0_checkpoint': 'tinker://5114900d3184a1f9e9047b5305999c3f/weights/confirm-treatment_dimuon_s0-step0', 'adapter_sha256': '51f089a87ece974104b8005791b54925d905618735136ff61525a9e4d5478e93', 'fp32_param_sha256': 'f276ed16271041f69577844cbda84339e64d1bdc810283d3d415212794783e54', 'server_checkpoint_optimizer': 'dimuon'}, {'arm': 'baseline_adamw_s1', 'phase': 'confirm', 'base_checkpoint': 'Qwen/Qwen3.5-2B', 'initialization_checkpoint': 'tinker://3237e16ec54b87586f4118a972d03f52/weights/confirm-init-s1', 'source': 'server_response', 'before_first_update': True, 'restore_count': 0, 'optimizer_checks': [{'after_restore': 0, 'before_next_update': True, 'optimizer': 'adamw', 'model': 'Qwen/Qwen3.5-2B', 'rank': 32}], 'initial_output_sha256': '6e2313c4c269801a8b9950b4ebee38fbda850114d334dccc1ea46abd084e51bc', 'evidence_ref': 'restore_check.json', 'step0_checkpoint': 'tinker://3237e16ec54b87586f4118a972d03f52/weights/confirm-baseline_adamw_s1-step0', 'adapter_sha256': 'c8a11ec8d00edf4b6b45d3feac3e799de096e46a9e3176aac67fdb14f0d8592b', 'fp32_param_sha256': 'fb777da03b0c3b627613a59d27d60508134ad05cb58b83a04a598c9b9c7d1908', 'server_checkpoint_optimizer': 'adamw'}, {'arm': 'treatment_dimuon_s1', 'phase': 'confirm', 'base_checkpoint': 'Qwen/Qwen3.5-2B', 'initialization_checkpoint': 'tinker://3237e16ec54b87586f4118a972d03f52/weights/confirm-init-s1', 'source': 'server_response', 'before_first_update': True, 'restore_count': 1, 'optimizer_checks': [{'after_restore': 0, 'before_next_update': True, 'optimizer': 'dimuon', 'model': 'Qwen/Qwen3.5-2B', 'rank': 32}, {'after_restore': 1, 'before_next_update': True, 'optimizer': 'dimuon', 'model': 'Qwen/Qwen3.5-2B', 'rank': 32}], 'initial_output_sha256': '6e2313c4c269801a8b9950b4ebee38fbda850114d334dccc1ea46abd084e51bc', 'evidence_ref': 'restore_check.json', 'step0_checkpoint': 'tinker://08e25db82a092035669aa384182fbeb0/weights/confirm-treatment_dimuon_s1-step0', 'adapter_sha256': 'c8a11ec8d00edf4b6b45d3feac3e799de096e46a9e3176aac67fdb14f0d8592b', 'fp32_param_sha256': 'fb777da03b0c3b627613a59d27d60508134ad05cb58b83a04a598c9b9c7d1908', 'server_checkpoint_optimizer': 'dimuon'}, {'arm': 'baseline_adamw_s2', 'phase': 'confirm', 'base_checkpoint': 'Qwen/Qwen3.5-2B', 'initialization_checkpoint': 'tinker://8eaad4366b3e3f1193bc20115d07490d/weights/confirm-init-s2', 'source': 'server_response', 'before_first_update': True, 'restore_count': 0, 'optimizer_checks': [{'after_restore': 0, 'before_next_update': True, 'optimizer': 'adamw', 'model': 'Qwen/Qwen3.5-2B', 'rank': 32}], 'initial_output_sha256': '6e2313c4c269801a8b9950b4ebee38fbda850114d334dccc1ea46abd084e51bc', 'evidence_ref': 'restore_check.json', 'step0_checkpoint': 'tinker://8eaad4366b3e3f1193bc20115d07490d/weights/confirm-baseline_adamw_s2-step0', 'adapter_sha256': '0c1377ebc59ba6d47f890fe6f1b04c3f019054b02af31da4bbca3f66e0c1fc0a', 'fp32_param_sha256': '6d3b9c3d0659410a206fe85843af48ad08a195d32987ccd2c83c3b6b10bf2db6', 'server_checkpoint_optimizer': 'adamw'}, {'arm': 'treatment_dimuon_s2', 'phase': 'confirm', 'base_checkpoint': 'Qwen/Qwen3.5-2B', 'initialization_checkpoint': 'tinker://8eaad4366b3e3f1193bc20115d07490d/weights/confirm-init-s2', 'source': 'server_response', 'before_first_update': True, 'restore_count': 1, 'optimizer_checks': [{'after_restore': 0, 'before_next_update': True, 'optimizer': 'dimuon', 'model': 'Qwen/Qwen3.5-2B', 'rank': 32}, {'after_restore': 1, 'before_next_update': True, 'optimizer': 'dimuon', 'model': 'Qwen/Qwen3.5-2B', 'rank': 32}], 'initial_output_sha256': '6e2313c4c269801a8b9950b4ebee38fbda850114d334dccc1ea46abd084e51bc', 'evidence_ref': 'restore_check.json', 'step0_checkpoint': 'tinker://c8db5bb847cd27aaacea58a0dd7561a8/weights/confirm-treatment_dimuon_s2-step0', 'adapter_sha256': '0c1377ebc59ba6d47f890fe6f1b04c3f019054b02af31da4bbca3f66e0c1fc0a', 'fp32_param_sha256': '6d3b9c3d0659410a206fe85843af48ad08a195d32987ccd2c83c3b6b10bf2db6', 'server_checkpoint_optimizer': 'dimuon'}], 'paired_init_matched_all_seeds': True}

launch

{'experiment_id': 'exp_71911f0fb9', 'context_status': 'snapshotted', 'superseded': False, 'mode': 'ordinary', 'purpose': 'Execute the selected saved experiment version.'}

launch_instructions

{'name': 'launch-instructions-dfb05d79fc61.md', 'sha256': 'dfb05d79fc617d09dc8cc7bd43ab453c9d15d2a4459ce6e8c431ef62b6e53e9f', 'url': 'https://rx.modal.dev/api/runs/run_07e69074dc/evidence/dfb05d79fc617d09dc8cc7bd43ab453c9d15d2a4459ce6e8c431ef62b6e53e9f'}

reported_outcome_reason

refuted

reported_verdict

refuted

restoration_validation

{'status': 'unverified', 'required': True, 'checks': [{'check': 'baseline_adamw_s0', 'status': 'unverified', 'reason': 'baseline_adamw_s0: missing or duplicate arm evidence.'}, {'check': 'treatment_dimuon_s0', 'status': 'unverified', 'reason': 'treatment_dimuon_s0: missing or duplicate arm evidence.'}, {'check': 'baseline_adamw_s1', 'status': 'unverified', 'reason': 'baseline_adamw_s1: missing or duplicate arm evidence.'}, {'check': 'treatment_dimuon_s1', 'status': 'unverified', 'reason': 'treatment_dimuon_s1: missing or duplicate arm evidence.'}, {'check': 'baseline_adamw_s2', 'status': 'unverified', 'reason': 'baseline_adamw_s2: missing or duplicate arm evidence.'}, {'check': 'treatment_dimuon_s2', 'status': 'unverified', 'reason': 'treatment_dimuon_s2: missing or duplicate arm evidence.'}], 'reason': 'baseline_adamw_s0: missing or duplicate arm evidence.', 'applicability': 'required'}

verdict_report

{'effect': 0.0006413611976204455, 'margin': 0.02, 'lower': -0.0003151326920100634, 'upper': 0.0015978550872509543, 'seeds': 3, 'confidence': 'weak', 'reasoning': 'Measured: Dimuon beat AdamW by 0.00064 nats on 500 test items in all 3 seeds, but the 95% paired-t interval [-0.00032, 0.00160] is entirely below the 0.02-nat success margin, so the prespecified criterion is not met (refuted). Inferred limits: both frozen LRs (AdamW 2e-4, Dimuon 3e-3) are at the top of their grids, so a larger LR could change the gap; the restore-replay optimizer-state check showed ~1% relative differences from bf16 state persistence (not exercised by this design).', 'grid_edge': True}